On
the left we have a current view of FMW No. 239 at Saumur. It can be
seen to have a "flat spot" on the right side as well. Period photos show
that the historic Montmirail had a flat spot of the right, but it
started several inches below where it starts on 239. Thus, we would
judge that our example is not the real Montmirail, but was named
and painted in her honor. However, the overall appearance of 239 would
lead us to think that she was one of the M4A2s received by the French as
Lend Lease during WW II, most likely by a unit of the 2ème Division
Blindée going by the presence of the side appliqué plates.
Two views of
the no pistol port D50878 turret on Number 239. The inset shows that it
was cast by Buckeye Steel which is listed as a turret supplier to
Federal Machine. For instance, in June 1943, Buckeye is reported to
have supplied 44 turrets to FMW which amounted to their entire M4A2
production for that month. The Buckeye (B in a circle) turret
information includes the casting date, in this case, May 1943, along
with the turret serial number 1785. A May casting would be appropriate
to a tank accepted in July, so most likely this turret is the original.
However, we would judge that this turret would have been assembled with
an M34A1 Gun Mount, so its current M34 gun mount was likely
retrofitted, perhaps to complete the display. (The casting marks
suggest it came from an M4A4.) Aside from the gun mount anachronism,
this turret strikes us unaltered WW II, even French going by the
fittings (1) on each side in the rear which, held a stowage box on
the bustles of many 2ème DB Shermans, like that seen in the
period photo of Montmirail in the previous caption. The
turret would have come from the factory with the Commander's Blade
Sight (2), and we suspect the French would have installed the Vane
Sight (3) as a modification while in the UK before D-Day. Modelers
might note that the turret ventilator (4) has weep holes which drain to
the rear. The cast bullet splash guard (5) in front of the engine
deck doors is Part Number C 99378. The piece is about 3 inches
high. It was formed to accommodate 9 bolts, although only 6 holes were
reamed out and used in this case.
During his visit, Pierre-Olivier
noticed that all of the pressed
metal fuel/oil/water labels on FMW 239 were surprisingly
intact and readable. Perhaps this Sherman has been stored inside for
much of its existence? All of the filler points on the original Sherman
with gasoline powered radial engine were for gasoline, so labels
weren't installed at first. However, shortly after the
introduction of the diesel engine, pressed metal labels were
affixed near each of the armored filler caps to help the crews avoid
contaminating the tanks with the wrong solutions. As seen
above, the "GASOLINE" label (1) was for the auxiliary generator.
The filler point protected by a bullet splash on each side of the
hull provided "DIESEL FUEL OIL" (2) to the fuel tanks directly
below in the engine compartment. The curved label was
for "LUBRICATING OIL," (3) and just below that we have a
straight "WATER" label (4). These labels are about 1 1/8
inches wide. The straight labels are 4 1/4 inches long and the curved
ones span about 8 inches at their widest. Three of the
removable locking pins have survived the years on this example. One can
see how small chains secured the pins. The chain was attached to a
little U-bolt (5) welded into the armor, and then to a looped wire
fitting (6) at the point where the locking pin bends. Note the slight
variation in the appearance of the armor filler cap castings
with two of them having flattened tops. We once measured one of the
cable clamp castings (7) and found it to be about 4 3/4 inches
long, 1 inch wide and 1 1/2 inches high. In the realm of extreme
Sherman minutia, we would point out that from our observations, the
"standard" position for the auxiliary generator's "GASOLINE"
label was alongside of and parallel to the armored filler
cap. This example and FMW 178 in Troyes have the label mounted as seen
here and there is no weld scar evidence that it was ever moved from the
standard position.
Our
final example comes to us courtesy of our globetrotting friend Jim
Goetz who examined this M4A2 based Duplex Drive [DD] Sherman in a field
outside of Belagavi (formerly Belgaum), India. We have some question
about the actual numbers, but British correspondence dated 2 August 1945
states that there were 86 DDs in India at the time with plans to send
over 100 more. As best we have been able to determine, half of the DD
tanks of B Squadron (~ 9) of the 25th Dragoons were actually loaded
aboard LSTs in Madras harbor, preparing to set sail as part of Operation
Zipper, the amphibious landings planned for Malaya. However, when the
Hiroshima bomb was dropped on 6 August, according to
John Leyin of
B/25th Dragoons, "we were ordered to get our tanks off the LSTs and to
assemble in the harbour." In any case, Jim visited 4 surviving Sherman
III DDs in India. Note that there is a Fisher built M4A2 based DD (1)
within sight of our subject. These tanks don't appear to have been shot
up, but simply left in place. At one time, this example had the USA
Registration Number 3056470 painted on as seen in the inset. This would
indicate that it was built in December 1943, FMW's last month of M4A2
production. The tank can be seen with the "usual" FMW or Pullman glacis
pattern characterized by the small bow machine gun casting (2) and the
antenna bracket (3). It has such late production features as the sharp
nosed E8543 differential housing (4) and pads indicating that it once
had a gun travel lock (5) and a siren (6) mounted on the glacis.
In this side view, we see the DD skirt without all the other
paraphernalia. This affords us a look at the rather
substantial box-like structure (1) that was welded onto the upper
rear hull plates of M4A2 based DD conversions. This does not appear on
M4A4 or M4A1 DD conversions, whose exhausts were directed up with
fixtures more like sheet metal wading stacks. The
structure continues down and angles in to enclose the area around
the exhaust and provides a channel for the gasses to escape upward
as shown in the inset. It is thought that FMW would have been factory
installing the side applique plates (2) and the bogies with upturned
return roller arms (3) by the time this tank was built in December
1943. Since it was converted to DD by the British, it would be hard to
determine if it retained its original turret, but most of the
manufacturers that left the Sherman program at the end of 1943
finished out production with such "no pistol port" turrets. Jim was
able to enter this tank and reported spending quite a bit of time
attempting to "reveal" the number stamped inside the dataplate frame.
Turns out it is "506." Doing the math on this, we have build
sequence # 1 = SN 14785, plus 505 units = SN 15290, which is
an exact mathematical match to USA 3056470, the Registration
Number that was formerly painted on. Combining this with the prior
examples, we consider it to be pretty good "weight of evidence"
confirmation that FMW stamped the exact build sequence number
inside the dataplate frame of its Shermans.
Here
we have an interior photo showing the transmission of USA 3056470. As a
matter of Sherman minutia, we would like to point out the odd shape of
the Power Train identification plate (outlined), since this is the first
instance of one of these that we have seen inside a surviving Sherman
tank. (That is not say that we get to look inside a lot of Shermans.)
The plate here is rusted unreadable but has the unmistakable outline of a
Mack Manufacturing Corporation Power Train plate. The inset shows a
readable example from an M3 Medium Power Train, Ser. Num. 2136. Company
records report that the Mack plant in New Brunswick, New Jersey produced
a total of 2652 M3 Medium P.T.s plus 361 spares from February 1941
through Feb. 1943, as well as 2280 M4 P.T.s from September 1942 through
December 1943. Photo courtesy of Mick Wilson. Inset photo courtesy of Midwest Military.
We thought we'd show a photo of the top of the turret since it
strikes us as unusual that a US made commander's vision cupola was
retrofitted. This modification kit was released in September 1944, but
doesn't appear to have gone into general circulation until the end of
the year. The evidence is that only a handful of 1942/43 production
Shermans received the mod during WW II, mostly during remanufacture. The
kit came with a "pedestal mount for cal. .50 anti-aircraft machine
gun," since, unlike the split hatch cupola it replaced, the all-round
vision cupola did not have an integrated pintle mount. The instruction
booklet includes diagrams with specific directions about the location of
the pedestal mount, which was about where we have placed the number 1.
However, on this turret, as well as on the other DD nearby, one can see
weld scars (2) showing where the pedestal was actually mounted. In 1945
until he went home in 1947, Trooper H. V. Phillips, a REME engineer with
25th Dragoons, took snapshots of a few of the unit's DDs. In some, the
vision cupola and pedestal mount can be seen retrofitted in this
configuration as on the right. The white of the rotatable section of the
hatch is somewhat unexpected. The evidence suggests that the vast
majority of Shermans had the interior of their hatches painted Olive
Drab. We would observe that the Sherman III DDs that Jim Goetz visited
in Ahmednagar and Jaisalmer do not appear to have received the vision
cupola modification. Item 3 is the "Sun Compass Bracket" which was
installed at US Tank Depots to Shermans assigned to Commonwealth Lend
Lease starting around mid 1943. The casting marks (4) indicate that the
turret was produced by Continental-Hubbard (H in a C). It has a very
high turret serial number of 3595, likely one of the last D50878 turrets
the company made. The British were not allocated any M4A2(75)s from
September 1943 through June 1944. Thus, we believe this December 1943
production unit would have been one of the 463 M4A2s allocated July
through September 1944. Most of these were remanufactured, some by
Federal Machine, which redid 317 M4A2s. However, USA 3056470 does not
show any signs of that, so we would guess it was shipped new.