The original periscope gun
sight was found deficient, so the Ordnance Department designed a new gun mount
that incorporated a direct sight telescope. A mock up (above) was photographed
at APG on June 22, 1942. The sides of the rotor shield were extended to protect
the telescope (1) and the .30 caliber coaxial machine gun (2). Designated
"Combination Gun Mount, M34A1," the new design was released for
production on October 16, 1942. Most changes to the Sherman were introduced
"with obsolescence." This permitted the manufacturer to use up
supplies of the old parts, even as the new parts were introduced into
production. The addition of the direct sight telescope was deemed so important
that the M34A1 was initially released "without obsolescence," with a
cut off date of January 15, 1943. The manufacturers could not obtain all of the
parts necessary to meet such a rigorous deadline, and ultimately, the M34A1 did
not completely replace the M34 gun mount in Sherman production until the end of
April, 1943.
Chrysler's
DeSoto division produced gun mounts, and the Detroit Tank Arsenal was an early
adopter of the M34A1. A company memo dated January 22, 1943 states, “we have
scheduled gun mount M-34A1 (76mm) [sic] to be incorporated in tanks after No.
3499 M-4A4. This tank will be built about February 15 and we do not anticipate
interruption of production to accomplish.” By our math, the 3499th M4A4 would
have been around SN 18652. A British Situation Report differs slightly in
noting that they had been advised that the M34A1 gun mount would be installed
on M4A4s in February, starting at serial number 18531. At present, the first
period photo we have recorded showing a factory new M4A4 with M34A1 gun mount
is SN 18776. Whatever the exact Serial Number, all of this leaves us with
little doubt that the introduction date indeed came in mid to late February.
The photos above provide comparative views of the early and late type M34A1 gun
shield castings. The late type appears to have been introduced by Chrysler in
early May, 1943, at around the same time as the incorporation of the positive
hatch lock mechanisms.
As originally designed, the Sherman’s D50878 75mm turret featured a pistol port on the left side towards the rear. The montage above shows the
pistol port in the open and closed positions from both inside and
outside the turret. One of the authors recently had the opportunity to
operate a pistol port, and his first impression
was that it was much heavier than expected. The L shaped handle or
“lever,” served as a simple prop, which held the door open, and locked
it into position by means of a “lever locking pin” (1) which could be
slipped into a “notch” (2) with a rotation of the
handle. To secure the pistol port door in the closed position, the
handle was rotated until a fixed “latch” (3) contacted a fitting (4)
welded on just above the pistol port opening. The “lever handle” (5) was
installed with a rubber bicycle type grip which
is missing from this example.
Users reported some
problems with the locking device of the pistol port. On top of that, Ordnance
Department tests found the pistol port to be a ballistic weak point. A couple
areas on the inside right front of the turret casting had been thinned to allow
for the proper operation of the traversing mechanism. As the first Shermans
entered combat, troops began to report that the enemy aimed for these
"thin spots." In April 1943, the D50878 turret was revised to
eliminate the pistol port, as well as "increase thickness of turret in
area of the traversing mechanism." The revised turret castings began to
enter the production pipeline at Chrysler around June, 1943. We estimate that
the last 1600 M4A4s were produced with either "no pistol port"
turrets, or earlier turrets with welded up pistol ports. Above provides two
views of M4A4s awaiting overseas shipment at the Hampton Roads Port of
Embarkation in September, 1943. These tanks would have been mid 1943
production, and can be seen with no pistol port turrets, and the
"interchangeable type" sand shields, which were standardized for the
M4A4 in May. Some of the British WD Numbers recorded from this series of photos
are T-212566, T-212567 and T-212573.
Starting around mid 1943, Tank
Depots were directed to weld up the pistol ports on the Shermans they processed
for shipment. As tanks with welded up or no pistol port turrets were delivered
to the troops, the feedback was universally negative. Without the pistol port,
it often took three men to load ammunition. A man on the ground passed rounds
up to a man standing highly exposed on the tank, who passed the rounds through
to a man in the commander's hatch. Only one man on the ground, and somewhat
protected by the tank, was needed to pass ammunition through to a man at the
pistol port. "In response to British requirements," any tanks
assigned to them, and awaiting processing in Depots, were exempted from the
"weld up the pistol port" directive. However, the Commonwealth
received many Shermans with welded up pistol ports. The scene above depicts one
such M4A4 of the Pretoria Regiment, 6th South African Armoured Division, near
Monzuno, Italy, December 28, 1944. In response to the demand, the pistol port
was reinstated on July 23, 1943, but the new turret castings didn't begin to
enter production until late 1943.
Period photos show 2 of the
Firefly (Sherman Vc) prototypes (T-148350 and T-148471) had welded up pistol
ports, but without the turret applique modification. This combination was
probably somewhat unusual in combat service, in that the idea in the Summer of
1943 was to correct the flaws of the original D50878 turret by the addition of
these mods. The Firefly at Bovington is another such
example. It is to be
noted that the turret patch kits were made available to the Commonwealth for
field modification in the months leading up to D-Day. Despite their position in
favor of the pistol port, it is obvious in period photos that the British
Firefly program involved a large number of M4s and M4A4s that had either welded
up or no pistol port turrets. The conversion program commenced in January 1944,
and many of the new, suitable Lend Lease Shermans with M34A1 Gun Mounts and Oil
Gear Power Traverse would also have lacked working pistol ports. Left side photo courtesy of Mathieu George.
In mid 1943, armor
applique kits were produced to protect the "thin spots" on earlier
turret castings. Approximately 900 of the first of these were shipped to the
Mediterranean Theater of Operations, and arrived in September. The turret
applique is often the only modification seen on early production Shermans
serving in Italy. Additional shipments were made to the UK starting in
September for installation on US and Allied Shermans slated for the D-Day
invasion. Soon US Army Ordnance officials in the UK were reporting back to the
Office of the Chief of Ordnance that the 350 pound patch coupled with the
weight of the M34A1 Gun Mount, created a nose heavy turret condition which
would require 1100 pounds of counterweight. OCO rejected the counterweight
idea, with the advice that retrofit of the new Oil Gear Traversing Mechanisms
which were en route to the UK in November and December was the Ordnance
approved solution to the nose heavy problem. It would appear that Chrysler only
factory installed the turret patches to welded up pistol port turrets used on
M4A4s in August and September, the last 2 months of new production. It was a
standard item where needed on every remanufactured M4A4. The photo above shows
the shape and overall appearance of the patch used by Chrysler. Note the
machining at the bottom edge of the turret casting (arrow). This is not present
on every D50878 turret, but is commonly noted on the turrets of surviving
M4A4s.
Quoted from a British status
report..."The installation of the 2" Smoke Mortar becomes effective
on vehicle No. 7300. This means that tanks coming off the production line as
from the 26th of August, will have these mortars fitted. Since only a total of
7500 M4A4s are being produced, we shall get 200 tanks from the final production
with these mortars in addition to the...reworked M4A4s." The British
repeatedly requested that the mortar be provided and installed by the US as a
standard item on Shermans. It was felt that a factory milling operation of the
hole would be preferable. Despite the difficulty of burning the hole in the
turret, which also weakened the surrounding armor, a number of earlier
production Shermans, particularly the Firefly conversions, were retrofitted
with the Smoke Mortar in Commonwealth workshops. The Brits often added an oval
shaped combing as shown on the right. The combing held some sort of canvas (?) cover, which,
according to a British schematic, was kept “in rear bin”. It should also be noted that US Tank Depots were charged with
installing the Smoke Mortar modification starting in the Fall of 1943. Left side photo courtesy of Carl J. Dennis.
The introduction of periscope
guards and the commander's vane sight to new production M4A4s is somewhat
murky. The photos above show USA 3031035, which was pulled from the line at the
Detroit Tank Arsenal and installed with the Allis Chalmers suspension and
tracks developed for the M6 High Speed Tractor project. This would have been
about the 7356th M4A4 produced out of 7500. 3031035 can be seen to have a
welded up pistol port turret with smoke mortar. It has just about every
modification available up to September 1943, including the full suite of armor
applique and the gun travel lock. However, it is "still" fitted with
the original commander's blade sight, and lacks the periscope guards. The new
sight and periscope guards were just entering the production pipeline as
Chrysler ended M4A4 production. Aside from processing tanks for shipment, the
Tank Depots served as modification backstops. As supplies became available in
Fall of 1943, the Depots were directed to install these items to Shermans
scheduled for shipment overseas. We suspect that the use of
welded up pistol port turrets (as opposed to those with no pistol ports) so
late in production, may have been a "last ditch" attempt to use up
remaining supplies of the earlier turrets.
The
"Sun Compass Bracket" (circled) is present on many of the turrets of
Commonwealth Lend Lease Shermans. The Sun Compass seen on some British AFVs
during the North African Campaign was a disc type affair, as on Monty's Grant
(inset). It might have been useful for navigation in the featureless deserts of
Egypt and Libya, but was hardly needed in the subsequent campaigns in Europe.
Despite the questionable utility, starting around mid 1943, the British
prevailed on the US to have the fitting welded on at Tank Depots to all
Shermans assigned to Commonwealth Lend Lease. We did not come across a list of
Depot modifications for the M4A4, but above right shows those for the
"British" M4A2 at Chester Tank Depot as of October 22, 1943.
"Install Sun Compass Brackets" is item 12. One might assume that a
Sun Compass was also provided as On Vehicle Materiel?
If
a Sun Compass was indeed provided as OVM on British Lend Lease
Shermans, it is almost certain to have been the “Compass, Sun, Universal
Type,
Abrams Model SC 1” as shown above. We would like to tell our readers
that this compass was found in its original wooden box inside a
surviving M4A4. However, it was actually purchased on EBay, and this
photo and a few others were sent to us by Mariano Paz
who thought we might like to see them. Here it is shown installed on
the existing bracket on the turret of Serial Number 18324. In a
subsequent caption, this tank is pictured when it was on display at the
Ministerio De Defensa in Buenos Aires, Argentina. In
the Spring of 2020, Mariano informed us that 18324 was being restored
to running condition. The compass was made by the Abrams Instrument
Company in Lansing, Michigan, and the Technical Manual, dated November,
1943 describes it as “a mechanical device which
utilizes the azimuth of the sun to obtain true direction.” A
sophisticated sun dial, if you will. The Manual provides directions on
how and where to use it, including, “On a tank, it should be mounted
outside the turret where the tank commander can observe
it when the hatch is open.”
Based on the paucity of period photos
showing any type of Sun Compass installed, we can only observe that its
use must have been extremely limited.
Remanufactured M4A4s
The US Army wanted to
terminate production of 75mm Shermans at the end of 1943. However, quoting from
General Bernard Montgomery, "The gun in the tank must be able to fire a
good H.E. shell...For this reason we definitely do not want any 76mm
Shermans." Thus, the British continued to require 75mm models in
1944. It was agreed that 75mm Shermans in the hands of troops in the US, would
be collected up and remanufactured in order to meet Commonwealth requirements
as far as possible. This consensus actually dovetailed nicely with US policy
"That rebuilt tanks be utilized to meet International Aid requirements to
whatever extent necessary to insure equipping United States troops in combat
theaters with the latest production type vehicles." M4A4s were recalled to
the Detroit Tank Arsenal starting in the Summer of 1943. For instance, the 7th
Armored Division is reported to have had 232 M4A4s on hand at Camp Young,
California. 100 were in transit back to DTA by late June, 1943. The scene above
is thought to have been photographed in the Spring of 1943. It shows 1942
production M4A4s of the 7th AD's 40th Armored Regiment on maneuvers at the Desert
Training Center. Note the absence of spot lamps and step brackets.
The
British and US agreed to certain conditions regarding the remanufactured
Shermans. All tanks would be equipped with M34A1 gun mounts and Oil Gear Power
Traverse. These were considered necessary by the Brits, in that they planned to
convert a number of these tanks to Fireflies. They also intended to convert
many to various types of "Funny Tanks," including recovery vehicles
and mine flails. For this purpose, they requested that 600 be shipped
"Completely Knocked Down" (CKD). This was often done with wheeled
vehicles, where the components were boxed to save shipping space. The vehicles
were then assembled in theater. The CKD request was denied by the US, since the
Lend Lease Protocol called for the shipment of combat ready tanks, not a
collection of unassembled parts. However, Chrysler was directed to provide the
British with everything left over at the end of the M4A4 remanufacture program.
Presumably, this "All Time Buy of Spare Parts" included Multibank
engines, Chrysler 3-piece differential power trains and other components no
longer needed for the later Shermans produced by the Detroit Tank Arsenal. The
well known photo above is dated June 1944. The rows of used M4A4s on the left
and center are on "disassembly lines," where they will be completely
stripped down. A few units nearing completion can be seen on the right along
with some new production M4A3(105)s. From a company memo dated October 30,
1943, “Rebuilding these tanks requires two and a half times as much work as
assembling the tanks new. They are to be completely torn down, then each part
will be inspected, cleaned, reconditioned, or replaced, whatever the needs may
be. Also certain modifications are to be made. In all respects they are to be
the equivalent of new tanks when they leave the Arsenal.”
The
designers of the T6 (Sherman pilot) made the unfortunate decision to
position much of the 75mm ammunition "up high" in the body of the tank.
As early as June 1942, the British contacted US Ordnance, and
recommended that the rounds be relocated to less exposed positions
"below the sponson line," in the floor of the hull. This could have
been done but would have created a serious interruption in
production that the Allies simply could not afford in late 1942.
Ultimately, most of the rounds were repositioned to the hull floor as
part of the major redesign of the M4 series that commenced in
July 1943. These "second generation" Shermans entered production
starting in January 1944, but, by then, there were thousands of
Shermans on the fighting fronts with the original ammo stowage.
Ordnance came up with a plan to provide them with greater protection,
which came to be known as the "Quick Fix" modification. The Technical
Manual illustration above shows the original M4A4 ammunition stowage
configuration. Note that the total number of rounds in the diagram
amounts to 97. On the previous page of the TM, the total number is
listed as 98, with 16 rounds in "left sponson forward of tool box,"
whereas the diagram shows only 15 rounds there (*). We have yet to come
across a 16 round rack, and suspect that ultimately, the left sponson
rack carried 15 rounds, the same as other Sherman models. In any
case, it can be seen that 30 of the rounds were stored in
the relative safety of the hull floor, "below the
sponson line" (highlighted in blue), while the remaining rounds were
located in more vulnerable positions in the turret basket or on the
sponson shelves (highlighted in pink).
20,000 "Quick Fix"
kits were produced from July through September, 1943. Manufacturers began
installing them on new production Shermans in August. As supplies became
available in the Fall of 1943, Tank Depots retrofitted the mod to Shermans
intended for overseas shipment. With this modification, 1 inch "sponson
side protector" plates (Chrysler drawings shown above) were welded to the
exterior of the tank in the areas of the sponson ammunition racks. Inside, the
racks were encased and "doored" in 1/4 inch armor. The turret basket
was "skeletonized," meaning that the sheet metal grating was removed.
This was a Commonwealth recommendation. They had experimented with
"skeletonization" on some of their early Shermans to provide for more
escape options, since the grating tended to isolate the turret crew from the
drivers. Ready rounds were deemed "worth the risk" by the British,
although any rounds clipped to the turret basket wall, defeated the purpose of
skeletonization. One British drawing provided an option for a total of "5
rds armoured" clipped beside the loader's seat. However, the "Quick
Fix" modification eliminated the original 12 unprotected ready rounds
completely.
A British officer described
the Quick Fix modification "as neither quick nor a fix," since the
ammunition racks were NOT relocated "below the sponson line," and the
entire procedure consumed over 140 man hours. It was necessary to remove the
turret in order to retrofit the 1/4 inch armor plates and doors to the
ammunition racks. Above shows 3 of the armored bins inside a restored M4A1. (We
hope to be able to provide a similar photo of an M4A4 in the future.) The 30
rounds directly behind the escape hatch were fitted with a folding armored door
(1). The 17 (2) and 15 (3) round racks on the right sponson were also encased
in armor, and fitted with doors. The 15 round rack on the left front sponson,
and the 8 round ready rack on the turret basket floor were protected in a
similar manner. Photo courtesy of Roger Condron.
Above left shows a pile of
original turret baskets at a remanufacturing facility. One can see that the
basket had 3 openings, but depending on the turret’s orientation during
emergencies, crew members could be trapped inside or outside of the basket. Above
right provides an unusual view of a skeletonized turret basket inside a
stripped out M4A4. In order to relocate the ammo racks to the floor of the hull
on the second generation series of Shermans, the turret basket was raised up to
the level of the sponsons. That is, the "well" of the original
design, as represented by item 1, was eliminated.
Crews liked to carry as much
ammunition as possible, and there was "a universal demand for ready racks
from battlefield commanders." Nonetheless, the 12 rounds clipped to the
original turret basket wall were eliminated by the Quick Fix modification, as
well as by the "second generation" Sherman redesign. Thus, the only
rounds immediately available in the turret were in an armored bin at the foot
of the loader. This decision was nearly as controversial as the decision to
eliminate the pistol port. Ready round proponents won out with the Sherman's
replacement - the M26, as it included 10 ready rounds. We suspect that the
instruction to remove the ready rounds was not always followed when the Quick
Fix modification was done "in the field" on a non-contract basis. A
few surviving remanufactured M4A4s have been noted to have the old ready round
clips. The question as to when and where this was done needs more study. A
British Report mentions that Base Workshops in the Middle East had made a
modification to the Quick Fix kits..."All conversions include the addition
of another layer of four rounds to the existing eight round ready bin on the
floor of the platform."
The applique armor on a new or
remanufactured M4A4 was applied very neatly with the weld bead running
"with the grain" as shown above. The welding often looks somewhat
different on plates applied in the field or at a Tank Depot. Part Number
A347061 was used on both sides in the front. In most cases, Chrysler (or its
subcontractor) appears to have applied the entire plate to the right front, but
in some instances, the top front edge was cut a bit in order to avoid the
glacis weld seam (inset).
Starting in August, 1943,
10,000 of the so called "hatch guard" modification kits were produced
for installation on new production Shermans, as well as those already overseas
or scheduled for shipment to combat zones. It was reported that DTA began
installing this mod to new M4A4s in August 1943 at Serial Number 22161. It was
also standard on the 1610 remanufactured M4A4s. For some reason, the Field
Service Modification Work Order which was published in late August only applied
to M4 and M4A3 Shermans. Thus, it is fairly common to see combat photos of
M4A2s and M4A4s with the Quick Fix applique, but not the hatch guard plates. On
the other hand, the Tank Depots did not discriminate in this regard, but were
directed to install the mod on all Shermans processed for International Aid.
Although the FSMWO does not
provide instructions for such a process, some surviving M4A4s have been noted
to have had the direct vision visors welded up before installation of the armor
plates. This can be seen above left on a remanufactured M4A4 that had the hatch
guard plates shot away on a target range. The FSMWO instructs that on tanks
equipped with a dust cover fastener ring, the top section of the ring be cut
and removed. The section was to be bent and reapplied to the hatch guard plate,
but the instructions note that the dust cover might "not fit
perfectly" afterwards. It is thought that the Detroit Tank Arsenal simply
replaced the old fastener rings with new ones instead, as seen above right.
On December 30, 1942, the Ordnance Department published Field Service Technical Bulletin No. 1731A-5: “The
taillight guard on some early production models of the welded hull
Medium Tank M4 series is improperly located and does not furnish
adequate taillight protection.” This was followed by instructions on how
to remove and relocate the existing guards to correct the issue.
As best we can tell from counting
heads, Chrysler was the only builder that made any welded hull Shermans
with the tail light guards improperly positioned. The TB’s directive was
either not disseminated to Chrysler, or ignored
as minor, as the evidence suggests
that most or all new production M4A4s
were built with the
configuration shown on the left.
In any case, one of the items required by the M4A4 remanufacturing program was "relocation of tail light guard"
so that they completely encompassed them as shown on the right.
Richard Hunnicutt, author of
the magnificent "Sherman, A History of the American Medium Tank,"
described the tank in the photo above as "a late production M4A4." However,
the USA Number, 3017084, indicates that it was originally accepted in December,
1942. The confusion arises because an M4A4 built in August or September 1943
(the last 2 months of production) will have a lot of the same modifications as
a remanufactured job. Many of the remanufactured M4A4s were 1942 production, so
some telltale signs of a remanufactured as opposed to a late production M4A4 can
be the presence of older features such as direct vision, padded hull lifting
rings, and "no lip" differentials. Remanufactured M4A4s were equipped
with the new commander's vane sight, whereas DTA appears to have ended new
production with the old blade sight. In some cases, both sights are present in
period photos, which would indicate that the new vane sight was added as a
modification. Late production M4A4s had welded up or no pistol port turrets,
while most or all of the remanufactures had turrets with working pistol ports,
and the "thin spot" applique patch. Note that the little step bracket
was eliminated with the introduction of the gun travel lock.
The
beautifully preserved Sherman pictured above is on display at the Imperial War
Museum in London. This tank has all the hallmarks of a DTA remanufactured M4A4.
Serial Number 19388 is stamped on both the front and rear towing lugs. That indicates that it was accepted in March, 1943.
From the Serial Number, we can determine through a math formula that this tank
was assigned USA 3019694. In the absence of a period photo or other
documentation, there would be no way to confirm if the painted on WD Number, T-232274,
is authentic. From the standpoint of counting heads, we can observe that the WD
Numbers of the "reworked" M4A4s, as the British called them, almost
all fall within the T-23XXXX and T-28XXXX ranges. If this tank still has its
dataplate, we would be very interested to see a photo of it. Examination of
surviving examples suggests that companies that remanufactured Shermans
replaced the original dataplate with a new one of their own. Since Chrysler was
both the original manufacturer and the remanufacturer, we've wondered what they
did? Both photos above courtesy of Carl J. Dennis.
There is a mathematical
correlation between the Ordnance Serial Number and the USA Registration Number
of AFVs built for the US Army during WW II. The British chose to use their own
War Department or "T-Number" system on their Lend Lease Shermans. These
numbers were assigned to each tank by a British representative, and painted on
at the Depots before the tanks were shipped. We've been asked numerous times,
but there is NO correlation between the T-Number and a US built tank's Serial
Number. Thus, there is no way to determine the maker or the production date of
a Sherman if all one knows is the T-Number. However, there is a loose
chronology to the way T-Numbers were assigned. In general, earlier production
Shermans will have lower T-Numbers. Remanufactured Shermans would be the
exception, as they were shipped in 1944. The table above is a very informal
"counting heads" survey of the T-Number ranges that we believe were
exclusive to the M4A4. There may have been some with T-26XXXX numbers. We've
recorded a few textual listings in that range where the tanks were described as
M4A4 or Sherman V. These may be typos, as period photos of Shermans in the
T-26XXXX ranges show a mix of radial engine models, including M4(75)s,
M4A1(76)s and M4(105)s. In any case, at present, we don't know of any photos
that show M4A4s with clearly readable T-26XXXX numbers.
World War II use of the M4A4
During
WW II, the M4A4 was used by more nationalities than any other type of Sherman.
The forces of Britain, Canada, France, Poland, South Africa, New Zealand,
Czechoslovakia, India, China and the US all employed the tank in combat. The
Soviets were allocated 2 units for evaluation in September, 1942. Yuri Pasholok published an online article, wherein Soviet Test Reports noted that
these were USA 3057449 and 3057484. Both would have been accepted in October,
1942. They arrived in the USSR via Iran at the end of
May 1943, 8 months after they had been produced. This is nearly twice
the average overseas shipping time for a new Sherman, and reflects the
difficulty experienced with getting Lend Lease supplies to the USSR. The
Soviets rejected the use of the M4A4, as they found the Multibank engine too
complex, and noted that the fuel consumption far exceeded that of their
preferred Sherman model – the diesel powered M4A2. The pristine M4A4 on display
at the Armor Museum in Kubinka has the USA Registration Number 3057449 stamped
into the differential housing, indicating that it was one of the test units. If
this tank is relatively “as built” inside, it would make a valuable historical
reference. Photo courtesy of Craig Moore.
For most of the conflict, the diesel powered
M4A2(75) was the predominant type of Sherman used by the Commonwealth in Italy.
Not all of the British "AFV Situation" Reports break down Sherman holdings by
type, but on November 20, 1943, it was reported that there were 1135 M4A2s "with
formations" or in reserve in Italy and North Africa. As with Sicily, the 1st
Canadian Armoured Brigade appears to have been the only unit in Italy fighting
with M4A4s at the time, and they are reported to have held 153. The British 1st
Armoured Division is the only other formation listed with M4A4s (64), but they
were reorganizing in North Africa, and did not arrive in Italy until May, 1944.
A further 377 M4A4s were listed with "Ordnance and Training" (presumably for
other Commonwealth units forming in North Africa) and 101 were in transit from
the US. Above shows what are thought to be M4A4s of the Ontario Regiment, 1st
Canadian Armoured Brigade in the Liri Valley, circa May 1944. The lead tank can
be seen with the interchangeable type sand shield strips and other features
which suggest Summer 1943 production. Most likely, this M4A4 was received as a
replacement in late 1943 or early ‘44. In March 1945, the 1st Canadian Corps
(including the 1st CAB), redeployed to Northwest Europe where it finished out
the war with the rest of the Canadian Army Overseas. Courtesy Canadian Army
Photo.
M4A4s
continued to arrive in theater, so that by September 23, 1944, the
number of Sherman Vs recorded as "with formations" in Italy had
increased to 961, almost on par with the 992 M4A2s reported. The 1st
Canadian Armoured Brigade, which had debuted the type in Sicily, was the
only Sherman formation at the time composed entirely of M4A4s at 174
units. The other units had a mix of Sherman types. For instance, the 5th
Canadian Armoured Division which had had its combat debut in May, 1944,
is also listed with 174 M4A4s, but this is supplemented with 46
M4A1(75)s. The 6th South African Armoured Division had the most M4A4s on
strength at 200, but also had 14 M4A1(76)s, a "new," 2nd Generation
model of Sherman, that had recently arrived in the MTO. These, along
with M4(105)s and Fireflies would be doled out in the MTO as they became
available. The veteran British 1st Armoured Division, had reorganized
in North Africa, and is listed with the most diverse group of Shermans,
including 33 M4A1(75)s, 45 M4A2(75)s, 75 M4A4s, 28 M4A1(76)s and 17
M4(105)s. Finally, the 7th Armoured Brigade is reported as having
105 M4A1(75)s and 56 M4A4s. The photo above features an M4A4 named
"Falkirk" and is captioned, "Two Sherman tanks of 6th Royal Tank
Regiment in action against German machine-gun positions on the walls of
San Marino, 19 September 1944." It would appear that the 6th RTR was
equipped with M4A4s, while the Brigade's other Regiments, the 2nd RTR
and the 7th Hussars, had M4A1(75)s. "Falkirk"
can be seen with a lot of 1943 modifications, including the full
applique treatment, periscope guards, and 2 inch smoke mortar. However,
no gun travel lock appears present, and the turret has no pistol port.
This leads us to speculate that this tank was not remanufactured, but
was built with these features in Sept. 1943, at the end of M4A4 production. Courtesy of IWM, photo NA 18734.
Click on the photo for larger size
The 6th South African Armoured
Division organized and trained in Egypt before being committed to Italy in
April, 1944. The interesting Signal Corps photo above is dated April 21, 1945,
and was probably taken in Casselecchio a little southwest of Bologna. At the
time of the 1945 Spring Offensive, the Division was attached to the US Fifth
Army. The Arm of Service marking seen on the lead M4A1(76) (item 1) is
"52" indicating the Pretoria Regiment. The British did not care for
the M4A1(76), and passed a lot of them off to their Commonwealth partners. Three
of the M4A4s appear to be new 1943 production, while the one with the gun
travel lock was more than likely remanufactured. Two of them are set up as
command tanks with antennas mounted on the glacis brackets (2). Both are
outfitted with reels for communication wires. The lead M4A4 can be seen with
the "Swabey Sight" (3) designed in the Middle East, and installed on
many Commonwealth Shermans there and in India starting in December, 1943.
Most
of the M4A4s were shipped to the UK. In the months preceding D-Day,
many were converted to Fireflies, DD Swimming Tanks, Crab Mine Flails
and Armoured Recovery Vehicles. M4A4s made up the bulk of Commonwealth
75 mm Sherman gun tanks in Normandy. At the end of June 1944, the 21st
Army Group reported they had 762 M4A4s, compared with 391 M4s /M4A1s,
and 316 M4A2s. 318 Fireflies were listed on strength, with all but 2
being M4A4 based (Sherman Vc). 180 Flails were all reported as "Sherman V
Crabs." 93 Sherman V Armoured Recovery Vehicles were on strength. Above
shows a Sherman Vc, thought to be with the 3rd County of London
Yeomanry, landing on Sword Beach, June 7, 1944. The appearance of this
M4A4 suggests May through July production. Most likely the smoke mortar
was added in the UK during the Firefly conversion. Courtesy of the
Imperial War Museum, Photo B 5130.
The British converted 693
Shermans to DD from March through December 1944. 400 were based on th M4A4, and
293 on the M4A2. ALL of the British DD conversions used for the Invasion are
believed to have been M4A4 based. We invite readers to have a look at our
Duplex Drive pages. As
best we have been able to determine, Commonwealth units embarked with
118 Sherman V DDs and 80 M4A1 DDs converted in the US. One of the
Canadian DDs was recovered off Juno Beach in 1970, and is on display at
Courseulles-sur-Mer, France (above, right). "Bold" is reported
to have been the tank of Major J.S. Duncan, commander of B Squadron of
the 6th Canadian Armoured Regiment (1st Hussars). This tank was one of
the approximately 50 DDs that sank or foundered in the rough seas while
trying to swim in on D-Day. The
serial number is not quite readable, but this M4A4 appears to have been
produced just before the introduction of the positive hatch lock
mechanisms, so probably early May 1943 acceptance.
The most successful of the numerous
British and US anti-mine devices was the Sherman Crab Mine Flail. Crab
conversions appear to have been based exclusively on the M4A4. Tests using the
Continental Radial equipped M4 concluded that it was unsuitable, as the engine
lacked the horsepower and torque to drive the flailing rotor at the necessary
revolutions per minute. It was reported that 336 Crab I and 211 Crab II had been
produced by the middle of 1945. Crabs were used in operations from D-Day to the
end of the war, most notably by the 30th Armoured Brigade of the 79th Armoured
Division. The 79th was an unusual formation, composed of various types of
special purpose armored vehicles, collectively known as "Hobart's Funnies." The
30th AB specialized in Flailing, and each of its 3 Regiments consisted of 45
Crabs. From D-Day on, units of the Brigade were detached in support of various
Commonwealth, and, on occasion, US operations. The Sherman V Crab on display at
Bovington carries the bull's head insignia of the 79th Armoured Division, and the Arm of Service marking
of the Westminster Dragoons, one of the Flailing Regiments of the 30th Armoured
Brigade. Photo courtesy of the late Massimo Foti, a fine photographer, and friend to Sherman Minutia.
The British are reported to have
converted a total of 169 Churchills and 221 Shermans to Armoured Recovery
Vehicles by mid 1945. 188 were based on the M4A4, and 33 on the M4A2. All of the
Sherman conversions were Mark Is. The improved Mark II, which incorporated a
winch, did not get past the pilot stage before the end of the war. ARVs were
used from D-Day to VE-Day, and were allocated on the basis of 1 per Squadron (
~20 tanks). The exact number issued to combat troops of the 21st Army Group is
unknown, but it is thought that, from month to month, the number never exceeded
100. Above shows some of “Hobart’s Funnies” north of Xanten, Germany on
March 23, 1945, during the preparations for Operation Plunder, the 21st Army
Group's crossing of the Rhine. The Sherman V ARV is believed to
have served with the 1st Lothian and Border Horse Yeomanry, another one of the
Flailing Regiments of the 30th Armoured Brigade, 79th Armoured Division. Courtesy of the Imperial War Museum, Photo
BU2080.
At the start of the Campaign
in Northwest Europe, the Polish 1st Armoured Division was almost exclusively
equipped with M4A4s. On June 30, 1944, while still in the UK, the Division is
reported to have held 139 Sherman V, 5 Sherman V Observation Post tanks, 23
Sherman Vc along with 2 Sherman Ic Fireflies, and 11 Sherman V Armoured
Recovery Vehicles. The photo above shows 3 M4A4 based units parked beneath a
landmark windmill in Terheijden, Holland in early November, 1944. These are
thought to be tanks of A Squadron, 2nd Polish Armoured Regiment. The ARV and
Firefly appear to have T48 rubber chevron tracks. The 75mm gun tank looks to be
a remanufactured job with a T-23XXXX War Department Number. Towards the end of
1944, supplies of M4A4s were exhausted, and elements of the Polish 1st Armoured
Division were re-equipped with the M4A1(76).
The French formed 3 Armored
Divisions, each of which was equipped with 165 Shermans. The 2ème Division
Blindée was entirely outfitted with M4A2s, and landed in France on August 1,
1944. Attached to the Third US Army at the time of the breakout from Normandy,
the 2ème DB drove forward and liberated Paris on August 25. The 1ère and 5ème Divisions
Blindées
each started with 110 M4A4s and 55 M4A2s, and were part of the 1st French Army.
During the invasion of Southern France (Operation Dragoon), the 1ère DB came
ashore on D plus 1, August 16, 1944. The Division estimated losses of 32
Shermans by D plus 30. The French had a very limited reserve pool, and many of
their losses were replaced with tanks from US stocks. Thus, by V-E Day, French
armored units had employed just about every type of Sherman, including the
M4(75)/(105), M4A1(75)/(76), and M4A3(75)/(76). The port city of Marseille was
liberated by French troops on August 29, and proved to be a great logistical
asset to the Allied effort in the European Theater. Above shows "St.
Quentin" of the 2ème Régiment de Cuirassiers /1ère DB. This tank had its original left
side drive sprocket (1) replaced. Quite a few photos show the unit's M4A4s with
T49 "interrupted parallel bar" tracks (2). We suspect the original
tracks had worn out during training, and were replaced before the unit shipped
out from Algeria. The tanks had been painted with the distinctive
"Invasion Stars" (3) as well.
While many of the M4A2s of the
2ème DB received modifications in the UK prior to D-Day, the Shermans of the 1ère
and 5ème DBs remained relatively unmodified throughout the war. Above shows
Général Jean de Lattre de Tassigny, Commander of the French First Army, during
ceremonies in Colmar shortly after the liberation of the city on February 3,
1945. The only modification evident on these M4A4s of the 1er Régiment de Cuirassiers / 5ème DB
is the commander's vane sight (circled). By the final months of the war, the
engines of the original French Lend Lease Shermans had worn out, and
replacements were requested. The only engine that was available from the US was
the Continental Radial. At least one French M4A4 was test fitted with the
radial during the war, but it is believed that most of the Transformé
work was done in the months and years after.
In 1943 and 1944, 623 Lend Lease 75mm Shermans were shipped to
Commonwealth Forces in India to supplement or replace the Grants and
Lees that had been sent earlier. The vast majority of these were
M4A4s/Sherman Vs, although some period photos show a small number of
M4A1s and M4A2s in the mix. They served with British and Indian units in
Burma in 1944 and 1945. It is thought that the first combat use may have
come in April 1944 during the 2nd Arakan Campaign when the 16 M4A4s of C
Squadron, 149th Regiment, Royal Armoured Corps fought in support of the
36 Indian Infantry Division. We could not find a photo of that action
so above shows Indian Army M4A4s of B Squadron, 19th King George V's Own
Lancers firing on Japanese positions near Udaung on 31 December 1944
during the 3rd Arakan Campaign. "Battleship," the tank in the
foreground, can be seen with the commander's vane sight (1), as well as
the "Swabey Sight" (2). These tanks do not have the usual British added
stowage bins, although some units have been seen with boxes, possibly
salvaged from M3 Lees, on the left rear sponson. Infantry phones (3)
have been added on the right rear. The tarp on the turret bustle looks
too big to be the standard OVM issue (there were complaints), so was
probably replaced in the field with one that would cover the whole tank.
The padded lifting ring (4), along with the orientation of the tail
light guard (5), serve to identify "Battleship" as a remanufactured
M4A4.
We could not resist including
the "atmosphere" shot above which is captioned, "The British
commander and Indian crew of a Sherman tank of the 9th Royal Deccan Horse,
255th Indian Tank Brigade, encounter a newly liberated elephant on the road to Meiktila,
29 March 1945." The glacis of this remanufactured M4A4 has been
"caged," but not wire meshed. This combination is presumed to have
been a defensive measure against Japanese infantry attacks with magnetic mines
and the like. Photos suggest that the M4A4s shipped to India were mostly late
new production with welded up or no pistol port turrets, or the remanufactured
jobs. Courtesy of the Imperial War Museum, Photo SE 3640.
The Chinese did not officially
receive any Shermans as Lend Lease. However, the Commonwealth "reverse
Lend Leased" 126 of their M4A4s in India "to USA Forces." These
augmented some 125 M3A3 Light Tanks already in use by the 1st Provisional Tank
Group. The unit was composed of the 230 man [US] 527th Ordnance Company, Heavy
Maintenance (Tank), along with 1800 Chinese soldiers. The first 12 M4A4s
arrived on April 19, 1944, and, one month later, 2 Medium Tank platoons, 1 US
crewed and 1 Chinese, joined the 1st Battalion Light Tanks in combat in the
Mogaung Valley in northern Burma. Above shows some early 1945 shipments to the
railhead at Ledo on the India/Burma border. T-289132 is a remanufactured 1942
production M4A4 with direct vision. In general, original parts were used on
remanufactured tanks. However, T-289132 can be seen with the newer upturned
return roller arms (1). These were introduced in late 1943, and became standard
on Shermans to the end of VVSS production. They eliminated the need for the
spacer installed on the earlier straight arms. It seems unlikely that many of
the original M4A4 straight return roller arms were rendered unusable during
training, so perhaps Chrysler ran short of spacers, and installed a few new
production upturned arms instead?
Two Battalions of the 1st
Provisional Tank Group had been equipped and trained in time to support the
final Allied Offensive in Burma. New and replacement tanks made their way to
the front through the mountains and jungles by way of the controversial Ledo
Road, one of the largest engineering projects ever undertaken by the US Army. The
photo above is dated December 13, 1944, and shows a convoy negotiating a
hairpin turn near Momauk, about mile post 362 on the 465 mile Ledo Road. With
the Japanese defeat in Burma, plans were made for a major offensive in China,
but the end of the war found the 1st Provisional Tank Group in Chanyi, China,
where it was deactivated on December 18, 1945. The Group's equipment was turned
over to the Chinese. According to Lt. Frank Pyle, a veteran of the 1st PTG, it
was "reformed as a separate armored force under the Nationalist Chinese
banner. The unit was lost near the Marco Polo Bridge in 1949 against Chinese
Communist forces." There may be a former 1st PTG M3A3 on display in
Beijing, but as far as we know, there are no surviving M4A4s on mainland China,
or Taiwan.
A
small number of M4A4s were used in combat by US Army troops in both the
European and Mediterranean Theaters. These were special purpose or
"funny tanks," provided from British stocks. Details are somewhat
sketchy, but it would appear that 20 Crab Mine Flails "were initially
obtained from the British in the United Kingdom." We interpolate that
some of these were received before or shortly after D-Day, since at
least two, "Hun Chaser" and "Hiwassee" appear in Signal Corps footage
shot during the Battle of St. Lô in mid July, 1944. In the screen
captures above "Hiwassee" can be seen with tactical markings (circled)
indicating HQ 29 of the 17th Armored Engineer Battalion, 2nd Armored
Division. It is thought that the Crabs were attached to the 29th
Infantry Division's Task Force Cota which made the final push to take
St. Lo on July 18th. At some point later in the Campaign, "15 additional
Crabs were immediately obtained from the British 21st Army Group on a
loan basis." In February, 1945 the US submitted a reverse Lend Lease
requirement for 105 units "to convert the two mine exploder battalions
to Crabs." We
would assume this is a reference to the 738th and 739th "Special Mine
Exploder" [SMX] Battalions which, at the time, were equipped with a few
Crabs, but primarily employed the US designed Mine Rollers, T1E1 and
T1E3. In the event, the requirement was cancelled due to the end of the
War in Europe.
The
6617th Engineer Mine Clearance Company was activated in Northwest
Africa in August, 1943, and appears to have been the US Army's first
"Armored Special Equipment" unit to engage in combat operations. Its
initial assignment came in May, 1944, when it employed 12 US built T3
Scorpion Mine Flails in support of the 1st Armored Division during the
breakout from Anzio. The T3s proved unsuccessful, and were removed from
service. After that, details are obscure, but it is thought that the
unit was assigned to the Invasion Training Center at Salerno where it
was photographed on June 20 during beach clearance and loading
exercises. Curiously, what appear to be the early versions of the US
produced M1 Dozer blades are seen attached to M4A4 Shermans in these
photos. We can only guess that the M4A4s were provided on the advice of
the British, who considered the Radial Engine of the M4/M4A1 to be
underpowered for dozing and flailing operations. A locally produced mine
scarifier (1) can be seen attached to the dozer blade in the photo on
the right. The use of the scarifier was stated to have been a
"satisfactory" method for removing mines on soft sand beaches, as it
simply pushed them to the sides. However, it was ineffective for use in
heavier soil. Also seen in the photo is a British supplied Churchill
tank (2) modified to carry a "small box girder bridge." The 6617th was
part of the larger Engineer contingent of the US VI Corps/7th Army for
Operation Dragoon, the August 15, 1944 Invasion of Southern France. No
history of the unit has been located so far, but an Observer's Report
states that, "Its present equipment includes 12 dozer tanks and 9 (?)
[sic] Churchill bridge layers." The 6617th was reported to have had 7
officers and 219 enlisted men, "and was so organized that it could be
broken down into detachments." The detachments were "Mine Gapping
Teams," each composed of 1 dozer tank with scarifier; 1 dozer tank "with
racked demolitions on the blade," and a T40 Rocket Launcher attached to
its turret; and 1 "Churchill tank equipped with a small box girder
bridge, additional demolitions, and carrying engineer personnel." These
teams were allocated to the 3 invasion beaches, with the idea that the
mine excavator or scarifier tank would lead, clearing a path through any
mine fields. The dozer tank would follow, and, by use of its racked
charges or rockets or both, would clear any obstacles that hindered the
mine excavator's progress. "The Churchill tank to be used for bridging
an anti-tank ditch or furnishing engineer personnel to place hand
charges when needed."
For
the actual landings, the Observer's Report states that none of the Mine
Gapping Teams employed bridge layer tanks during the assault, since
they took up too much space on the limited number of landing craft
available, and their inclusion was considered "impractical."
Furthermore, little if any use was made of the T40 Rocket Launchers
during the landings "because of lack of confidence" in them as a result
of crew experiences during training exercises. Indeed, the teams
assigned to "the 3rd Infantry Division did not carry them as they
thought the tank bull-dozer would be overloaded...[and that] the rockets
constitute a hazard as they are vulnerable to small arms fire." In the
end, most of the the landings went easier than expected, and some of the
Mine Gapping Teams were not needed. However, "It was reported that one
team... less the bridge, successfully negotiated a heavily mined area
without a loss." The photo on the left above was taken by a local in
Moirans, France. "ENGR MC CO" can be seen painted across the front of
the tank. Note the rocket launcher fittings (1) on the turret, along
with the dozer fittings (2). The photo on the right shows the same tank
in Grenoble on August 22, 1944. We believe that both of these photos
were taken on the same day, and that the tank was part of a Mine Gapping
Team attached to the 143rd Regimental Combat Team of the 36th Infantry
Division which pushed inland 200 miles in a week, and liberated Grenoble
on the 22nd. Left side photo courtesy of "a local in Moirans" via Laurent Fournier.
As
mentioned previously, we have not yet located the After Action Reports
or other history of the 6617th, but the unit apparently continued in
service in the ETO, and was reported to have been redesignated the
"6638th Engineer Mine Clearing Company" in November, 1944. A footnote to
its story may be found in the form of a very cut down M4A4 hulk rising
up out of the ground near the beach at La Nartelle in Sainte-Maxime, France on the Riviera.
For whatever reason,
the tank was never recovered by the Army after the assault, and became a
bit of an attraction for the locals, some of whom posed with it as
shown on the right. We suspect "Night-Hawk" was part of the 6617th Mine
Gapping Team that landed on this beach in support of the 45th Infantry
Division. The tank was stripped down by the locals over the years, but
what remained was turned into a monument in 2014. The notches
(circled) on the differential housing
are clues that this Sherman was once equipped with an M1 Dozer, and the
fact that it is an M4A4 would lead us to identify it as a unit of the
6617th.
Post-war use of the M4A4
The M4A4 was declared obsolete
by the Ordnance Technical Committee on July 19, 1945. Figures are hard to come
by, but some M4A4s were retained post war by the countries that had received
them. France in particular kept a number of M4A4s in service, many of which
were supplied to Israel starting in the mid 1950s. The Indian Army is reported
to have had some Sherman Vs on strength as late as 1966. The British seem to
have "surplussed" most of their Lend Lease Shermans soon after WW II,
in favor of home built designs, such as the Comet and Centurion. Above is a
photo thought to have been taken in Rome in 1949 in celebration of the third
anniversary of the New Italian Republic. The foremost tank is an M4A4 with 75mm
gun. Next in line are pair of 105mm Shermans, and after, a mix of 75mms and
Fireflies. These would have been a sort of informal, pre NATO military aid,
made up of surplus Shermans left behind at the end of WW II in Tank Dumps in
Italy. Starting in the early 1950s, the Italians received 850 M26 through M48
series tanks from the US as part of the Mutual Defense Assistance Program.
Egypt was another post-war
user of the M4A4. In his book “Egyptian Shermans,” author Christopher
Weeks has it that a little over 100 M4A4s and M4A2s were purchased in the late
1940s and early 1950s. These Shermans appear to have been former Commonwealth
WW II Lend Lease, acquired perhaps under questionable circumstances, from tank
dumps in Italy and North Africa. Period photos suggest that the majority were
M4A4s, although it would seem that many (or all?) had their original Chrysler
Multibank engines and M4A4 engine decks swapped out for the GM Twin diesel
power plants and engine decks from M4A2s. Earlier we mentioned that, post WW
II, the French replaced the Multibanks of many of their M4A4s with Continental
Radial engines (see transformé link). It is thought that the French
provided the Egyptians with materiel and technical assistance, but details
about the chronology of the diesel engine swap are sketchy. However, we can
observe that several historic photos dated 1952 clearly show M4A4s retrofitted
with M4A2 engine decks. The example shown above was photographed during the
“Three-Month Anniversary of the Revolution Parade” in Cairo on October 23,
1952. In a number of photos, the M4A4’s exhaust deflector (1) appears to have
been enlarged and modified. We suspect it was repurposed for use as a rear
stowage bin. Egyptian Shermans had their combat debut during the Second
Arab-Israeli War which started on October 29, 1956. By that time, most of
Egypt’s armor was of Soviet design, but the 3rd Armored Battalion was deployed
on the northern coast of the Sinai Peninsula, and was equipped with
approximately 52 Shermans, including 12 Sherman/FL-10 Hybrids. The Battalion
was overrun and all of its tanks were lost as the Israelis captured the entire
Sinai Peninsula in just 4 days. After the 1956 War, Egypt provided most of its
remaining Shermans (~50 units) to the Gaza based 20th Palestinian Liberation
Army Division, in order that they might have a supporting tank battalion. In
the “Six Day War” (June 5 to June 10, 1967), the defenders of the Gaza Strip
put up a fierce fight, but were eventually overwhelmed, and all of the
Palestinian Tank Battalion’s Shermans were either captured or destroyed. Photo courtesy of the Bibliotheca Alexandrina, President Naguib Collection.
Here we have a surviving example of an M4A4 that had its original
Multibank engine replaced with a diesel. In the top right photo, it can
be seen that the engine decks from an M4A2 Sherman were also retrofitted
as part of the engine change process. The bottom right shows the
installation of the M4A2 exhaust onto the M4A4's lower rear hull. Note
how the M4A4's engine access doors were retained but cut down to fit.
This tank was formerly displayed at the Yad-Mordechai Museum in Israel.
It is thought that it may have been one of the Shermans of the Egyptian
3rd Armored Battalion captured in 1956. Pierre-Olivier examined this
tank while it was undergoing restoration in France. He found the serial
number 6189 stamped on the rear tow lugs, indicating that it had been
accepted in December 1942. Chrysler also stamped the serial number on
the front towing lugs, but this tank had had its original 3-piece
differential/power train replaced with a 1-piece, possibly from the same
M4A2 that was the source of the engine.
The document above details
sales of "Surplus Tanks for Scrap in Belgium" in 1946 by the British
Disposals Commission. The total "scrap" value was over 32 million
Belgian Francs. The vast majority of the AFVs can be seen to have been
Shermans. They were located in 2 dumps near Antwerp, the larger (167 R.V.P.)
was materiel "transferred by the Canadian Army on withdrawal of that
force." The other dump was British surplus. Officers assigned to the
Commission were responsible for seeing to it that the AFVs were scrapped, but
they had been reassigned due to budget cuts before all of the AFVs were
processed. As it was, many were NOT demilitarized or scrapped. It is thought
that these would be the entries in rows 6 through 17 above. Some were
requisitioned by the Belgian Ministry of National Defense, but others were
exported without license to Argentina. This created something of a diplomatic
flap among the governments of the US, Great Britain and Belgium. The 2 European
countries basically claimed that they did not know anything about the exports. In
any case, Argentina got hundreds of AFVs, and Belgium got thousands of tons of
desperately needed wheat. Document from British National Archives,
FO.371/72931.
We can not provide an accurate
number of Shermans exported to Argentina. In his book, "Blindados
Argentinos," Ricardo Fogliani states that a 1950 Inventory lists 206
Sherman Firefly and 154 Sherman "con canon de 75mm." Something
more than 360 may have been exported out of the Canadian Dump in Belgium (one
Net source states "nearly 450"), but perhaps some were not runners,
to be used as parts junkers? Fogliani has it that by 1962, the inventory had to
decreased to 154 Firefly and 114 75mm. The decreasing numbers over 12 years may
suggest cannibalization of some to keep others running? In any case, while most
of the surviving Shermans in Argentina were significantly upgraded, there are a
few 75mm's and Fireflies that are still in close to Commonwealth WW II
configuration. The remanufactured M4A4 on display in Buenos Aires is Serial
Number 18324, indicating that it was originally accepted in February 1943. This
example can be seen with the alternate part number D50993 on the left section
of the differential housing.
"Blindados
Argentinos" has it that in the late 1970s, 120 Shermans were upgraded with
Poyaud 520 diesel engines, and French designed FTR L44 / 57 105mm guns, license
built in Argentina. The 40 or so surviving "Sherman Repotenciados"
all appear to be former Fireflies. It is thought that they were used for the
conversion because the ammunition stowage had already been rearranged to
accommodate larger rounds. In order to provide room for the 17 pdr ammunition,
the bow gunner was eliminated with the Firefly conversion. The Repotenciado
conversion eliminated another crew member, the loader, since the gun had an
auto loading feature. The photos above show a couple of Sherman Vc based
Repotenciados on display in Argentina.
After the Firefly, the
French/Israeli designed M-50 is perhaps the most interesting conversion that
made use of the M4A4. In a manner very similar to the Firefly conversion, the high
velocity 75mm gun of the French AMX 13 was installed in a modified
"small" (D50878 or D78461) Sherman turret, with loader's hatch added
where needed. The first 25 M-50s were finished in time to fight in the 1956
Sinai Campaign. It is not known just how many M-50s were based on the M4A4, but
they were certainly well represented, and saw extensive service with the
Israeli Defense Forces up to 1973. Many were acquired from post war French
stocks of M4A4T’s, powered by the Continental R-975 radial engine. During
refurbishment or rebuild, additional units were installed with the readily
available radials, and many were retrofitted with later Sherman power trains
with 1-piece differential housings. Beginning in the early 1960s, M-50s were
updated with a 460 HP Cummins diesel engine, plus an array of stowage and other
equipment. This process also included conversion to HVSS suspension. Several
surviving M4A4 based M-50s are privately owned, such as the nicely preserved
example formerly of the Littlefield Collection in California. This M4A4 was
originally accepted in January, 1943, and can be seen to have standard hull
lifting rings on the front, and padded rings on the rear. Photos courtesy of Chris Hughes.
The exact number of M50s
produced has been somewhat elusive, but in an online article entitled “The
Tanks of ‘67,” Dr. Michael L. McSwiney states that “In 1967 the Israelis
had 179 M50 ‘French’ Sherman tanks.” Following retirement from active service
with the IDF, a few M-50s were employed as defensive bunkers along Israel's
borders. Some of the hulks remain in place to this day. The early M4A4 based
M50 shown above was emplaced in Metula along the border with Lebanon. (Update:
A colleague visited Metula in the Spring of 2017, and found that it is no
longer there.) This is not the only example noted to have had a pistol port cut
out of another turret, and welded in to what is presumed to have been a "no
pistol port" turret. Photo from Wikipedia Commons.
A few M50s continued in
foreign service long after their retirement from the IDF. In the 1970s and
beyond, M50s were supplied to the South Lebanon Army and the Lebanese Forces.
In the early 1980s, 48 M-50s were sold to Chile. These were refitted with
General Motors diesel engines, and rearmed with 60mm hyper-velocity guns,
developed in Israel. For penetration purposes, the gun was considered to be on
a par with the NATO 105mm. Above shows an example on maneuvers. The Chilean
M-50s were in service well into the 1990s. There were numerous border conflicts
between Chile and Argentina in the late 20th Century, but it does not appear
that the Chilean M50s ever “exchanged shots” with the Argentinean
Repotenciados. Photo courtesy
of Javier Munoz, via Fernando Wilson and Tom Gannon.
Not as well known as the M50,
was the “Sherman/FL10 Hybrid” which the French provided to the Egyptians in
1955, at about the same time as they began supplying M50s to the Israelis. This
was a much simpler effort to up gun the Sherman. Rather than modify the
original turrets to accept the high velocity 75mm gun of the French AMX 13 as
on the M50, the Sherman turrets were simply replaced with the oscillating
turret from the AMX 13 Light Tank. The FL10 turret was rather small, so only
had a two man turret crew - the commander and the gunner. There was no loader
as the gun was provided with an auto loading feature. The auto loading system
utilized two 6 round revolving magazines, and when the 12 rounds were fired,
the crew had to break off combat, and actually get outside of the tank to
reload these magazines. Also several sources report that the auto loader was
slower than a human loader. Thus, while the Sherman/FL10 Hybrid was armed with
the same main gun as the M50, the auto loading system no doubt limited the
effectiveness of the design when compared to the M50. The exact number of
Sherman/FL10 conversions is unclear, but it is thought that during the 1956 and
1967 wars, the Israelis captured or destroyed a total of around 25 units. Some
sources report that the Israelis converted a few of the captured Egyptian
Shermans to M50s. Three or perhaps four Sherman/FL10 Hybrids are known to have
survived. All are M4A4s with M4A2 engines, decks and exhausts retrofitted. In
the Spring of 2017, Jim Goetz examined the example on display at Latrun in
Israel. He reported that “17622” is stamped on the rear tow lugs, indicating
that this M4A4 was accepted in January, 1943. Note the “padded” hull lifting
rings (1), typical of M4A4s built January, 1943 or earlier. Many of the
Egyptian Shermans are seen with the "Quick Fix" armor applique plates
welded to the sides. We suspect that Serial Number 17622 had the modification
added in a Commonwealth workshop during WW II. At some point additional plates
were added to each side. So far, this is the only example of an Egyptian
Sherman that we have seen in this odd, “3 per side” applique armor
configuration. Photo courtesy of Jim Goetz.
Items
of interest in this rear view of Serial Number 17622 include the shell ejection
port (1) and the French designed smoke dischargers (2), which are also present,
two per side, on many of the turrets of Israeli Shermans. It can be seen that
the standard M4A2 exhaust and muffler system (3) has been retrofitted. Unlike
most Sherman models, M4A2s did not have engine access doors on their lower rear
hull plates. However, the original M4A4 access doors (4) were not removed and
blanked off during the engine conversion, but were simply cut in half crosswise
as seen here. Air scoops (5) were not required on M4A2s, while they were
standard on M4, M4A1 and M4A4 Shermans. Available evidence suggests that
the air scoops were retained on the Egyptian M4A4s with M4A2 engine retrofits.
The item circled is obviously a door bumper. These were not standard on “as
built” M4A2 engine decks, but are seen in many of the period photos as well as
most surviving examples of Egyptian M4A4s with M4A2 engine retrofits. The rear
engine deck plates of many Egyptian Shermans are seen with a pair of rather
large “handles” which form a stowage rack. These appear to have broken off of
SN 17622, but can be seen in the inset on SN 21064, a “regular” Egyptian M4A4
with M4A2 engine retrofit, which is also on display at Latrun. Note as well the
addition of a pair of (adjustable?) rods running across the engine deck plate.
It is thought that the rack was part of a series of modifications done on
Shermans at Base Workshops in the Middle East during WW II. The M4A2 door
bumper retrofit also appears to have been part of this series. In any case,
these items are present on many of the surviving Egyptian M4A4 to M4A2
conversions. Inset photo courtesy of "Bukvoed" via Wikipedia.
The M4A4 Technical Manual
states that "The vehicle serial number is stamped on each boss (two front
and two rear) to which the towing shackle is attached to the hull." Anyone
looking for the Serial Number on a surviving M4A4 is advised to check first on
the rear towing bosses, since the original differential housing may have been
replaced over the years.
Above
shows the dataplate from the Sherman V Firefly on display at the Pansarmuseet
in Axvall, Sweden. Note that the Serial Number, 16733, is stamped in the upper
right hand corner. As mentioned previously, this M4A4 would have been accepted
in December, 1942. However, it shows obvious signs of having been one of the
1610 M4A4s remanufactured by Chrysler for British Lend Lease. We suspect that,
during remanufacture, Chrysler replaced the original dataplate, which would
have had “1942,” stamped inside the box on the lower left, with this one
stamped with “1944.” “A B Q” can be seen stamped inside the box on the lower
right. These were the initials of the Chief of the Detroit Ordnance District, Brig.
Gen. Alfred Bixby Quinton Jr., who
accepted this tank from Chrysler. Gen. Quinton’s initials certify that Serial
Number 16733 was built, or in this case remanufactured, to the prescribed US
Government standards.
In
2023, during a subsequent visit to SN 6189, the former Yad-Mordechai
Museum display, Pierre-Olivier was able to photograph the dataplate
after it had been stripped and cleaned. We include it here, since the
text is more readable than our previous example.