For
the "mushroom" type hull ventilator in the right rear, Ford cast the
piece with the asymmetrical bolt pattern that was typical of all welded
hull Shermans with the exception of Pressed Steel Car M4s. These same
ventilators on M4A1 cast hull Shermans and PSC M4s had symmetrical bolt
patterns. The reason for the difference may
have had to do with the way the hull roof angles down along the axis
indicated by the red lines on all but PSC welded hull Shermans. Ford
ventilator castings are noted with the part number "C 99377" stamped
into the top such as seen on SN 2893 in Long Prairie, Mn.
The
photos above were taken in Rittman, Ohio where SN 12454 (July 1943) is
on display at the American Legion Post. The left side image shows the
armored fuel cap covers, with the locking pins intact. To keep them from
getting lost, the locking pins were secured with a bit of chain which
has long since disappeared from these. However, a couple of the eyebolts
(circled) that held the chain to the hull are still present. Ford
produced armored fuel cover castings are observed with the part number
"C 84811" stamped into the top of the piece as seen in the photo on the
right. The part number is also cast into the side of the piece
(outlined), but it is an unreadable blob, which may be the reason that
the part numbers of many Ford castings were stamped on as well. For
future reference, note the weld scar (arrow) from where the side plate
of the engine deck bullet splash was removed to permit the installation
of the torsion bar hinge (1).
Ford used a cast piece throughout for
its headlamp sockets (1). On Shermans, headlamp plug holders (2) were
initially mounted parallel to the glacis. Our research indicates that
Ford repositioned them to the "final," vertical position in November
1942. Most likely this was done to keep the plugs from falling out of
the holders. To prevent them from getting lost, the plugs were secured
with a small chain as seen here on SN 11578 (December 1942). This was
one of two Ford M4A3s used in the 1984 film "Tank" starring James
Garner. The left side photo was taken at the Restoration Shop at APG,
but SN 11578 is now on display at the fine US Marine Corps Museum in
Quantico, Virginia as seen in the photo on the right. As a matter of
minutia, we would point out that SN 11578 would not have been built
with the "high bustle" turret it has now. Left side photo courtesy of
Mark Corbett.
As mentioned earlier, Ford had its own steel production facilities at
its massive River Rouge complex. The company produced armor plate for
its M4A3s and M10A1s, but the Government also contracted with Ford for
additional plate which it then supplied to other manufacturers. Ford
invented a process in which armor plate was quenched and straightened at
the same time by means of specially designed presses. This is reported
to have "saved so much time that the actual cost per pound of finished
armor plate...was little more than three cents, while other companies
were selling similar plate for from thirty-five to fifty cents!" Ford
armor plate can be identified by a simple "F" stamping (above left). Many
cast parts were manufactured at "the Rouge." For some reason, Ford used
"GAD" for its caster's logo rather than "Ford." Note how the "GAD" bow
MG casting is welded into the armor plate, the standard Ford
configuration by October 1942. The raised "line" running across the top
is typical of GAD, D47526 bogie bracket castings as seen in the photo on
the right. The Government supplied GAD gun mounts, suspension
components, and other castings in some quantity to other builders.
Ford documents mention that they machined the turret castings that they
received from their outside suppliers. The photo above shows some
machined D50878 turrets at Ford. The contour of the right front (white
arrow) would indicate that these are the revised D50878 castings that
eliminated the pistol port and introduced the so called "cast in
thickened cheek." This would tend to date the photo at about mid 1943.
We try to look for little differences in the way various companies
produced things, and what caught our eye here is that the drain holes of
the ventilators do not drain straight to the front or rear as seen on
most Sherman turrets but are on an angle of about 5 o'clock (red arrow).
This prompted us to look at the turrets on as many surviving Fords as
we could. Consequently, we are convinced that the 5 o'clock orientation
was a Ford thing. While doing that, we observed that the ventilators on
Ford hulls have the same quirk with the left side draining at 5 o'clock
and the right at 7 o'clock. From start to finish, Ford M4A3s were
outfitted with what hobbyists refer to as "low bustle turrets." Note the
downward angle (black arrow) of the low bustle turret. This angle on
"high bustle" turrets was much closer to horizontal. The location of the
casting marks (circled) suggests that all 3 of these turrets were
produced by General Steel Castings Corp. at their Eddystone Pennsylvania
Foundry.
The
photo on the bottom left shows the location and configuration of the
D50878 casting information on a General Steel-Eddystone no pistol port
turret like the ones in the photo of the previous caption. With
the "SER" prefix, there can be no doubt that 4807 is the turret's serial
number. The "E" suffix indicates that the piece was cast at General
Steel's Eddystone plant. Note the 5 o'clock position of the ventilator's
weep holes which we consider to be an indication that the turret was
machined and finished at Ford. During the process, we believe that Ford
very helpfully stamped the machining date on the turrets. For instance,
this example has "7-26-43" [July 26, 1943] stamped into the area around
the gunner's periscope housing as shown in the top left photo. We
maintain a list of surviving GS turrets and have recorded that 3985(E)
in Blackfoot, Idaho is the lowest turret SN recorded to date on a Ford
processed no pistol port GS-E turret and 5194(E) is the highest. Of
course, the dates could not be read through the paint layers on many of
the turrets, but we have collected a nice representative sample of 14
dates. The earliest is 5-29-43 on SER 4035 and the latest is 8-19-43 on
SER 5070. This is reflective of the time period when the no pistol port
turret was in the production pipeline and takes into account that Ford
left the Sherman program in September 1943. General Steel-Eddystone was a
major producer of turrets, and these were supplied to other
manufacturers, Canadian built M4A1 Grizzlies and Fisher M4A2s in
particular. We thought that, when Ford left the program, their excess
turrets might have been passed on to Montreal Locomotive who began
Grizzly production in October 1943. We can observe that of the 50 odd
surviving Grizzlies all but one or two have GS-E no pistol port turrets.
However, of those we have been able to examine, the ventilator weep
holes drain straight to the rear, and we have not seen any with dates
stamped in. In any case, turret 4807(E) sits on SN 11603 in Philipsburg,
Pa. This M4A3 would have been accepted in December 1942, long before
the no pistol port turret was even on the drawing boards. Since it lacks
the applique mods, we would judge that SN 11603 was not rebuilt during
WW II but was in the 1950s. Its original turret likely ended up on
another 1950s remanufactured M4A3.
Ford's main supplier of turret castings was General Steel, and the
company had another foundry in Granite City, Illinois, which was known
as the "Commonwealth Plant." The examination of surviving Fords would
lead us to conclude that they also supplied turrets to Ford. The casting
info on these turrets is positioned next to the ventilator and very
helpfully includes what we assume is the month and year the turret was
cast. The example above left is dated "12-42" with the "C" suffix
indicating the Commonwealth facility. We are pretty sure that some
Commonwealth turrets were produced before December, but this is the
earliest date we could actually read on the turrets we have been able to
examine. When the spotlight fittings and the ventilator were added,
they often obscured the Commonwealth casting marks. For instance, we
think that this turret might have been Serial Number 312 but the
(removed) spotlight fittings (*) interfered with our ability to get a
good read. There are traces of the machining date in the area around the
gunner's periscope housing, but we could not get a good read of that
either due to paint build up. The ventilator drains to the 5 o'clock
position which we take to indicate that the turret was machined by Ford.
This turret has a working pistol port which is not really appropriate
for the hull it is on, Serial Number 12454 (July 1943) in Rittman, Ohio.
The example on the right shows 4-43-C, turret Serial Number 1064 with a
machining date of 5-1-43. Of interest is that this turret has a
welded-up pistol port and the applique patch on the right front. Recall
that in mid-April, the Ordnance Department ordered the elimination of
the pistol port and directed that any further pistol port turrets on new
construction have them welded up, at either the factory or at depots.
Based on the dates, we suspect that the pistol port on turret number
1064 may have been welded up when the turret was machined at Ford.
However, this turret is on Serial Number 11826 (March 1943) in
Middletown, Ohio so, again it is anachronistic. We study the turrets
separate and apart from the hulls since so many of the surviving Ford
hulls do not have turrets appropriate to their original build dates.
Both the GS-Eddystone no pistol port turrets, and the GS-Commonwealth
produced turrets are seen with General Steel's distinctive "G inside a
shield" caster's logo on the turret bustle. As a matter of minutia, we
would observe that on the examples we've encountered, the logo is
positioned a few inches lower on the Eddystone turrets (left) when
compared with the Commonwealths (right). We take the fact that both of
these turrets have the ventilator draining to 5 o'clock to be an
indication that they were machined by Ford. The no pistol port turret
sits on SN 12306 (June 1943) in Denver. The turret serial number is 4035
(E) and the date stamped around the gunner's periscope is 5-29-43. We
can observe that all 19 of the GS-E no pistol port turrets that we have
been able to examine and record have the turret lifting rings cast in
(circled) as opposed to welded on. If this turret is not original to SN
12306, it is certainly appropriate. The welded-up pistol port turret on
the right is on SN 12126 (May 1943) in Princeton, MN. As is often the
case, the month that this turret was cast was "overwritten" by the
installation of the ventilator as seen in the inset. The turret serial
number is 980. The date stamp around the periscope is not readable.
Based on the 4-43 date on turret 1064 shown in the previous caption, we
would guess that 980 was also cast in April. Again, it is an appropriate
turret for SN 12126. Of the seven turrets we have recorded with the
Commonwealth "C" marking next to the ventilator, all but one have the
turret lifting rings cast in as opposed to welded on. We would mention
that we have not encountered any GS-Commonwealth no pistol port turrets
on any surviving Fords. However, two examples have been observed on
other Shermans. These are turret serial numbers 1273 and 1300, both with
casting dates of 5-43-C. Commonwealth turrets seem to "disappear" from
surviving Shermans after that, and we wouldn't be surprised if the plant
stopped producing D50878 turrets around mid 1943.
Our examination of surviving Ford M4A3s indicates that the Eddystone
plant produced some earlier D50878 turret castings with pistol ports. On
these, the casting information is placed below the pistol port. The
General Steel logo can be seen, somewhat poorly formed, behind the
D50878 turret part number. The GS logo is not repeated on the turret
bustle of these. The serial number of the turret on the left is 2376(E)
which is on SN 11849 (March 1943) in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. This is the
most readable example we have encountered. The location of the casting
marks below the pistol port seems to have been a poor choice, since in
some cases, the information was either distorted when cast, or got
ground down to provide clearance for the fire extinguisher housing
and/or the mushroom ventilator. The marks on the turret of the M4A3 in
Winooski, Vt. show such an example. Most of the "under the pistol port"
turrets are noted with welded on lifting rings. We have not been able to
collect much dating info from these but would guess that GS-E used this
location from the beginning of 1943 to the end of April.
Quite
a few surviving M4A3s have turrets that have no casting marks on the
exterior. We suspect that most of these are the earliest General Steel
D50878 turret castings. We had thought that the "G in a shield" casting
mark might have been inside on the "ceiling", such as has been noted on
two surviving Grant turrets (left inset). Most surviving examples of
"plain turrets" on M4A3s are on display as monuments with the hatches
welded up, but the turret on the M4A3 at Ft. Moore seemed like a
possibility. However, Dave Hobbs and Jim Goetz were able to get in and
have a look around and reported that the only marks visible on the
ceiling were by the turret bustle; just the turret part number, "D
50878." And there was no "C" or "E" suffix that might suggest General
Steel. So that will remain a mystery for now. This tank was once on
display at Fort Benjamin Harrison in Indiana. When the facility was
closed in the early 1990s, the M4A3 was moved to Ft. Knox where it was
placed inside the "LST" building, a replica of the tank deck of an LST.
It was moved to Ft. Moore, Georgia along with most of the Patton
Museum's armor collection starting around 2010. For years, this M4A3 was
identified as SN 2804, but during his visit, Pierre-Olivier was able to
"reveal" that it is actually SN 2809 (right inset). The commander's
cupola seen here was assembled from GAD castings and is typical of the
type of cupola used by Ford throughout production. The positive hatch
locks are reported to have been introduced into production in April
1943. Note that both the turret ventilator and the one on the left front
of the hull drain to the odd 5 o'clock position. We consider the
secondary antenna bracket seen here to be the first type used by Ford.
The photos on the left show what we consider to be the first type of
secondary antenna bracket used by Ford. This appears to have been a
U-shaped casting with a blank-off plate bolted on inside the form. On
other types of Shermans, these brackets are generally seen with drain
holes. Counting heads suggests that, sometime in late 1942, Ford
transitioned to a different bracket as seen in the photos on the right.
The body of this is a single piece and may also be a casting. A
blank-off plate was bolted to the top. Again, there was no drain hole,
at least not at first. The first type is noted on all of the surviving
turrets that don't have any casting marks on the exterior. The second,
or one-piece type makes its first appearance on a surviving turret with
an October 1942 casting date. It seems to completely replace the first
type by early 1943. The second type is noted on all of the extant
General Steel-Eddystone turrets that have the casting marks under the
pistol port as well as those with no pistol ports.
We have collected "Armor Casting Production, Scheduled and Actual
Shipments" statistics for 4 months including October and December 1942
and February and June 1943. During those months, General Steel is listed
as the sole supplier of turrets to Ford. However, evidence from
surviving turrets would indicate that Ford obtained a few castings from
Buckeye Steel and Pittsburgh Steel Foundry. On the left we have one of
the five Buckeye turrets encountered. Note the "B in a circle" logo and
the casting date "1-43" [Jan. 1943]. The others noted are dated 10-42, 11-42, 2-43 and 3-43. It is assumed
that the turrets would have been available to Ford a month or two after
the casting dates. All have cast lifting rings, and 4 have working
pistol ports. The 3-43 (March 1943) turret has a welded-up pistol port.
Pittsburgh Steel Foundry turrets are not common on surviving Shermans of
any type, and we have only come across one example on a surviving Ford
as shown on the right on SN 11762 in Estral Beach, Michigan. We take
this to have been original equipment on a Ford M4A3, since like all of
the other turrets we have discussed, the ventilator drains to 5 o'clock.
Like Buckeye, PSF very helpfully dated their turrets and this one can
be seen as 11-42 [November 1942]. We take 81 to be the turret serial
number, suggesting that, in late 1942, PSF had only recently begun
producing D50878 turrets. A surviving PSF turret dated 6-43 has serial
number 1075, so they do not appear to have been a high output turret
manufacturer. Going by the data available in "Armor Casting Production",
they might have averaged a little over 100 turrets per month. PSF
turret 81 has a working pistol port and cast lifting rings.
Because
most served as training vehicles in the US during WW II, Ford M4A3s
have survived in greater numbers than other 1942-43 production Shermans
(about 100 units). The M4A3s in the photo above appear to be "as
built," which was usually the case with Shermans in the US. The
"padded" hull lifting rings combined with the vertical headlamp plug
holders, suggest a production date between November 1942 and January
1943. There was a critical shortage of rubber at the time, and Ford was
contracted to produce the particular type of "three bar cleat" steel
tracks that can be seen on these tanks. The above Signal Corps photo is
part of a color series unfortunately captioned "desert maneuvers, USA,
1944." The fall foliage seems inappropriate for the desert, as does the
year. Tracing their movements, we think it is more likely that this
series shows units of the 10th and 81st Tank Battalions, 5th Armored
Division at Pine Camp, New York in the Fall of 1943.
Many surviving Ford M4A3s show evidence of having been
remanufactured once during WW II, and again in the early 1950s. The
three Tank Depots and Montreal Locomotive remanufactured 681 M4A3s from
August 1944 through April 1945. These are only described as "M4A3, 75-mm
gun", so may have included a few Second Generation Fisher M4A3(75)Wets.
Most of the remanufactures done in 1945 would not have been available
for overseas shipment because of their late date of production. The
photo above shows a trio of remanufactured M4A3s at Ford's Richmond
[California] Tank Depot in Fall 1944. RTD remanufactured 48 M4A3s from
August through November 1944. For the most part, these reflect the
appearance of the few small hatch M4A3s seen overseas in period photos
in 1945. Note how the sand shields were modified to accommodate extended
end connectors. The fender supports appear to have been installed 10
per side, using the round, adjustable braces, such as those used on
M4A1(76)s with HVSS. Only the leftmost tank has the late, sharp nosed
differential housing and a gun travel lock. As mentioned previously, the
evidence suggests that the late diff, gun travel lock and full suite of
applique armor began to be factory installed at Ford at roughly the
same time - August 1943. Thus, approximately the last 250 units would
have been built with these features. The other two tanks probably
required more modification work on the part of the remanufacturer. The
absence of gun travel locks most likely indicates that RTD was not able
to obtain them for the reman program. The absence of bow machine gun
dust cover fittings seems like an odd omission, and certainly "out of
spec." The instructions in the Field Service Modification Work Order for
installing the drivers' hatch guard plates directs that on tanks
equipped with a dust cover fastener ring, the top section of the ring be
cut and removed. The section was to be bent and reapplied to the hatch
guard plate, but it was noted that the dust cover might "not fit
perfectly" afterwards. Unlike other Shermans, Ford continued to position
the siren on the left front fender throughout production. Judging by
this photo, the Richmond Tank Depot did not alter this configuration
during rebuild. All 3 of these tanks can be seen with the original blade
sight along with the commander's vane sight which we assume was
retrofitted. These M4A3s appear to have retained their original
commander's split hatches. The commander's all round vision cupola was
wanted for the various remanufacture programs, but new production Second
Generation Shermans had priority for these until supply caught up with
demand. However, RTD apparently got its hands on a supply of another
Second-Generation feature, the gunner's improved sight and armored
periscope guard (inset). Our search for the inset photo leads us to
observe that the armored periscope guard is "not that common" on
surviving Ford M4A3s.
Here is another photo we came across
in the Richmond Tank Depot files at the National Archives in College
Park, Maryland. This Ford M4A3 can be seen as USA 3054260 (May 1943)
and was likely shipped to RTD after being used as a training tank on a
base in the US. The welder appears to be finishing up the installation
of the 1-inch applique plates that protected the sponson mounted
ammunition racks inside. Note that the forward plate was installed
complete, that is it did not have the upper corner cut at an angle
(arrow) as observed on some examples. This application likely required
grinding a bit of the weld seam where the plate overlapped. The
"Increase thickness of turret in area of traversing mechanism" or what
is informally called "the thin spot patch" was said to have been
factory installed at Ford in late April, but we expressed doubt about
this earlier. USA 3054260 would have been Serial Number 12105. It was
probably accepted on the same day as SN 12099, the one that was used in
comparative trials against a pair of British tanks. It is obvious that
these were not built with "the thin spot patch" likely because Ford was
not able to obtain the kits when promised. The patch was comprised
of two 1 1/2-inch castings formed to the contours of the turret. Here,
they appear to be propped up against the turret waiting to be welded
on. The patch weighed 350 pounds and combined with the additional
weight of the M34A1 gun mount, created a front heavy turret "requiring
application of approximately 1100 pounds, counter-weight to the left
rear outer surface of the turret" according to a memo from the ETO,
sent in November 1943 as the theater began installing the patches to US
Army Shermans in the UK before D-Day. The response from the Ordnance
Department's Modification Section was that the front heavy condition
had been taken into consideration when the M34A1 Gun Mount was
designed, and the "turret patch" was released, but that these changes
were "considered more important factors than additional unbalancing of
the turret." The use of counterweight was rejected as impractical.
Since the nose heavy problem was limited to hand traversing the turret
on steep slopes, the Ordnance Dept.'s solution was to standardize on
the new, more sensitive, "modified cam" Oil Gear Traversing Mechanism
for all new production Shermans starting around mid 1943. In addition,
1700 new Oil Gear kits were shipped to the UK in late 1943 for retrofit
to the US Army Shermans there. Ford appears to have begun production
with the Oil Gear Traversing Mechanism. Like SN 12099, USA 3054260 can
be seen with the early version of the M34A1 gun shield. We wouldn't be
surprised if the turret had a welded-up pistol port. Note the long
trailer towing pintle.
The
reason for the "the thin spot patch" is shown above on the left. Two sections of the right front interior
of the turret were scooped out to prevent "the knuckles of the operator
from being skinned or barked when using the hand traversing mechanism."
As the Sherman entered combat, reports came in that the enemy aimed for
these "thin spots." When the D50878 turret was redesigned, the thin spot
problem was remedied with what modelers term "the cast in, thickened
cheek." Pierre-Olivier has examined the interiors of a few no pistol
port, "cast in, thickened cheek" D50878 turrets, such as the shown in
the photo on the right. He has found the armor surface to be flat with
no scooped-out areas, but reports that there does appear to be a general
outward bulge in the right front. This leads us to think that the armor
in this area of the turret shell was actually moved out a bit to give
the operator room to work the traversing mechanism without scraping his
knuckles on the turret wall. On the exterior, it is likely that the
protruding part of the turret casting was not really "thickened" but was
intended to maintain the as designed armor basis of 3 inches on the
front and 2 inches on the sides. We have no way of measuring this, but
if we are right, the useful descriptive term "cast in, thickened cheek"
would be something of a misnomer.
As mentioned earlier, 34 Ford M4A3s or about 1/3 of the surviving
examples, have been observed to have the M34 gun mount modified to
accommodate the M70F coaxial telescope. The evidence suggests that a
modification kit was ordered in the Fall of 1943 in order to satisfy a
requirement concerning the US Army pool of approximately 1000 M4s and
400 M4A1s that were in the U.K. in the months preceding the D-Day
Invasion. All of these tanks were ordered to be equipped with the newly
designed M70F telescope which none of them had. To that end, 1440 M70F
telescopes were shipped to the UK between September and November 1943.
It was noted that about half of the US Shermans in the UK had the M34A1
Gun Mount, but all of those were equipped with the earlier M50
telescopic sight, so they could be upgraded fairly easily. However, the
remaining 700 or so Shermans had the earlier M34 gun mounts which had
been built with no provision for a telescopic gun sight. The solution
was to provide a modification kit, but "some time must elapse before
these kits can be manufactured and shipped to the United Kingdom." As it
turned out, the production of the kits was seriously delayed, and in
the end, a sufficient number of M34A1 gun mounts were shipped to the UK
so that almost the entire US pool was equipped with M34A1s with M70F
telescopes before D-Day. It is obvious that a sizable number of the M34
modification kits were eventually produced and period photos show that
some of them were used on M4 and M4A1 Shermans remanufactured by
Chrysler-Evansville and International Harvester in 1945. This was likely
because the supply of M34A1 gun mounts available to the remanufacturers
had been exhausted by then, and the modified M34 was considered an
acceptable substitute since it could mount a coaxial telescope. We don't
as yet have any photos of remanufactured M4A3s at Montreal Locomotive
but based on the rather large number of surviving Ford M4A3s with
modified M34 gun mounts, we think that MLW must have used some of these
kits as well. Above left is the last of the 1662 M4s and M4A1s
remanufactured by Chrysler-Evansville, tied up with a bow and ready to
go on 18 May 1945. On the right is an M4 Composite at International
Harvester. I-H remanufactured a total of 1026 M4s and M4A1s from August
1944 through March 1945. The company only rebuilt 26 M4s in 1945, all in
March, and based on the E9 suspension, we suspect that this was one of
them. It would appear that, at some point, both companies were directed
to apply extended fenders to their remanufactured Shermans. Period
photos suggest that both companies used round, adjustable braces, 10 to a
side to support the extended fenders. Those installed with the E9
modification, such as the above, also show the round braces, 10 per
side, even though the E9 kit came with 36 flat fenders braces to be
installed 18 to a side. We suspect that the requirement for full
installation of sand shields was dropped on Shermans remanufactured with
E9. One of the first instructions in the E9 modification pamphlet is
"Remove sand shields and tracks. Discard sand shields."
We thought we'd make a few observations about the modified M34 gun
mounts since they appear on quite a few surviving Fords. We have not
observed any casting marks on the "extension pieces" welded to the
original M34 rotor shields. It might be assumed that the marks were
placed on the inside of the casting. All of the surviving extension
pieces appear to have a sort of circular "blemish" (*) that interrupts
the smoothness of the casting. The surviving examples "tell" us that
these extensions could be applied to the early type of rotor shield as
well as the later type with the protective side pieces.
Almost all of the "end cap" pieces are noted with "OSF" (1) on the
bottom, which is the caster's logo of the Ordnance Steel Foundry of
Bettendorf, Iowa. The most common mark observed at the top of the piece
is "7070" with "162" (2) right below it as seen in the photo on the
left. We had originally thought that "162" might have been the serial
number of the casting, but "7070/162" is consistent across the samples.
Less common is the configuration seen in the photo on the right. These
raised numbers (3) are unreadable on the few examples we have seen, but
we suspect that they might have been "7070162" all on one line.
Here we have a view from the top, so to speak. It can be seen that part
of the original gun shield was cut away to permit the installation of
the telescopic sight and its movement coaxially with the gun. The
lifting ring on the right was removed and the gun shield was drilled
with a threaded hole (1) in which users could insert a screw eye for
lifting, in the manner of the later M34A1 gun mount. An elevation stop
(2) was welded on to the gun shield as seen here.
"A tank of 1st Division, US First Army, destroyed on outskirts of
Rottbitze, Germany...March 20, 1945." Photographs such as this, along
with a few text only Registration Number casualty listings, provide
evidence that a small number of remanufactured Ford M4A3s were shipped
to the ETO as replacements in late 1944 or early 1945. The last digit
of the RN is unclear, but our best guess would be USA 3054299 (inset),
which would have been accepted in May 1943. It is thought to have
belonged to the 745th Tank Battalion, since they were attached to the
1st Infantry Division at the time. The directive for the installation
of sand shields at factory or depot seems to have been a waste, since
it is obvious that they were not popular with combat troops. Here one
can see how the side fenders were extended out from the hull to
accommodate the extended end connectors. Flat, not round, fender braces
were used here, and this particular example appears to have 9 braces.
The blanket roll rack and the machine gun stowage on the turret bustle
would have been other items added during remanufacture. The bogie
wheels may have been replaced during remanufacture, but period photos
suggest that Ford used either the "pressed spoke" type seen here or
welded spoke wheels during production. The sheet metal exhaust
deflector was obviously flimsy and was replaced with an armored type in
new production early 1945, too late for it to see much overseas service
during WW II. It is thought that Montreal Locomotive installed armored
exhaust deflectors on some of the M4A3(75)s the company remanufactured
in 1945.
The
Signal Corps photo on the left above is dated 12 April 1945 and the
caption reads, "Troops of the 89th Division, Third US Army, mop up as
tanks move through the streets of Blankenheim [sic], Germany." Some
researchers have studied the matter using modern map software and
determined that the actual location of the corner where both of these
M4A3s were photographed is at the Zum Guildenen Zopf in Blankenhain in
Thuringia." It would appear that the caption writer confused
Blankenheim, which was over 300 km behind the front lines by 12 April,
with Blankenhain. The tank is only a small part of the photo, but we
have zoomed in on it for this discussion. Elements of the 707th Tank
Battalion were attached to the 1st Battalion of the 353rd Infantry
Regiment, 89th ID at the time. It might be assumed that this Sherman
would be an M4, but we identify it as a Ford built M4A3 by the unique
location of the antenna bracket. This tank has a number of
modifications that suggest remanufacture including extended fenders,
although they appear to have been broken off on the right side,
possibly from contact with a building. Like USA 3054295 of the previous
caption, it "still" has the original commander's split hatch, most
likely because the all-round vision cupola was not yet available to the
remanufacturing firm. Note the lifting rings on the gun shield, typical
of the early M34A1 gun mount. The "T-shaped" towing shackles (circled)
don't show up in photos of Shermans overseas before 1945. Counting
heads suggests that they were installed on new production Shermans
starting around October 1944. "Quick Attaching Cable Tow Hooks" kits
appear to have been provided to Remanufacturers and Tank Depots towards
the end of 1944. On the right is a screen capture from some Signal
Corps footage showing the same scene in Blankenhain. We identify "A-5"
as a Ford M4A3 as opposed to a Fisher M4A3(75)W by the absence of spare
track holders on the upper rear hull plate. On this example the
commander's all round vision cupola has been retrofitted along with the
pintle for the .50 caliber machine gun which was part of the cupola
modification kit. Note that a "long" trailer towing pintle is just
visible on "A-5."
This
well-known photo shows "Destination?" USA 3054660 (July 1943) as she
"rumbles down Berlin's famous Potsdamer Strasse July 4, 1945, as the
Second U.S. Armored Division enters the German capital to take over the
American zone and complete joint Allied occupation of the city." So,
two years after she was built, "Destination?" and her crew found
themselves in Berlin. Earlier, we showed photos of USA 3054661 engaged
in a "Power Train Efficiency Test" at APG in September 1943, which
provides more of an idea of the "as built" appearance of a July 1943
M4A3. The no pistol port turret seen on "Destination?" may not
necessarily be the original, but it is appropriate. The "black hole" on
the turret is some sort of spot in the photo, not combat damage. We
would assume that the front and side applique plates were added at a
Tank Depot or more likely during a remanufacture. Just visible are the
lifting rings of the early M34A1 gun shield.
There are at least 7 photos of
"Destination?" providing us with everything but a rear view. Some of
the captions describe her as "the first American tank in Berlin" so it
seems that she was followed around by a photographic team. The tactical
markings in the front shot identify the vehicle as with the 67th
Armored Regiment of the veteran 2nd AD. The tank name suggests D
Company, and in another photo, the GI guiding the tank moves over, and
"D-15" is seen painted on the left. Additionally, a roster that appears
to have been compiled from a survey of D Company members lists the tank
and crew names of 35 of their AFVs. Only the Tank Commander of
"Destination?" is noted - Ken Challender. "Find
A Grave" describes him as "an Army Veteran of World
War II serving as a First Sergeant, with Company D - 2nd Armored
Division under General George Patton." We might assume that Sgt.
Challender is the man in the commander's hatch. The few other D Company
Shermans seen in period photos of the time are M4A3(76)s, as one might
expect. These include "Daytona Beach," "Dec. 7th" and "Daisy Mae." It
would be interesting to know when, where and why Sgt. Challender drew a
First Generation Ford M4A3. "Destination?" can be seen with an E4186
differential housing, which would still be appropriate, although Ford
is reported to have introduced the later sharp-nosed diff towards the
end of July 1943. This tank does not have the extended fenders typical
of many but not all remanufactured Shermans. Nor does it have extended
end connectors installed. However, the fitting below the
painted-on weight disc is a single extended end connector welded on to
the differential housing. These are seen in pairs on some 2nd AD tanks,
and it would appear that they were used as brackets to support
supplementary "armor" fitted to the glacis such as in the inset.
An interesting quirk seen in the photo on the right is the lack of the
front applique plate (arrow).
Above shows SN 12390
(June 1943) in a storage lot at the Saumur Tank Museum, where
it is crammed in with other AFVs and difficult to photograph. This tank
has the appearance of a WW II era remanufactured M4A3. This
and S/N 12306 in Denver are the only surviving Fords we know of
that still have the "as built" engine deck configuration.
Pierre-Olivier examined it and noted that there are weld scars along
the sides suggesting it once had flat braces supporting extended
fenders. P-O was permitted to get inside and photographed the
dataplate. Unfortunately, it is rusted unreadable (inset), but the
initials "A.B.Q." are faintly visible in the box at the lower right. We
shall explain that later in this piece, but this leads us to think that
SN 12390 has an original Ford dataplate, perhaps the only surviving
example. Since it is in Europe, the authors suspect that it was
one of the few Fords shipped there during WW II. There is at least the
interesting possibility that it may have been issued to a combat unit
before VE-Day, or perhaps it remained in a depot unissued as the war
ended. The painted-on markings are in honor of "Montmirail", an
M4A2 of the 501ème Régiment de Chars de
Combat, 2ème Division Blindée. Ford M4A3s may have
been the one of the few Sherman types that were not used by the French
during WW II, or at least P-O has not been able to find any evidence
that they were.
Photographic evidence and one
textual listing indicate that a small number of Ford M4A3s were also
sent to the PTO, although they only appear to have arrived as
replacements in time to see service on Okinawa. The records of the
763rd Tank Battalion list a single "M/4A3w/75mm" that has a Ford
Registration Number - USA 3054824 (August 1943 production). On 12 May
1945, this tank was reportedly disabled by a mine and later satchel
charged, burned and written off as a complete loss. The iconic Signal
Corps photo above, dated 21 June 1945, shows a much larger scene, but
we have zoomed in to feature the interesting mix of Shermans. We
identify the M4 Composite in the center as a POA-CWS-H1 flame tank of
the 713th Tank Battalion by the metal frame (1) mounted on the left
rear sponson, a fitting that appears to have been exclusive to the
713th. The tank, which has been retrofitted with a highly prized
all-round vision cupola, seems to have become stuck or disabled. The
three other Shermans appear to be "circling the wagons" in an attempt
to protect it. The M4 Composite on the left is likely another 713th TB
flame tank. The tank on the right is a Fisher built M4A3(75)W with
fittings for the T6 Floatation Device visible on the front and rear.
The Sherman in the foreground has the rear hull plate of an M4A3 but
can be identified as a Ford built small hatch by a number of features
such as the applique armor on the side of the hull, ventilator on the
hull shoulder, rectangular bullet splash behind the turret, lack of
spare track stowage on the hull rear and the small mudguards at the
rear of the sponsons. The caption has it that these are "Four tanks of
the Army's 77th Infantry Division." The records of the 713th TB note
that on 21 June, a section of the 3rd Platoon of Company A "operated E
of Madeera with the 305th Inf." [a Regiment of the 77th ID.] We can't
Identify the unit affiliation of the M4A3s from the various records
available, but would note that on the days before and after 21 June,
Company A of the 713th TB "operated with Co C of the 763d Tk Bn."
The
5 Shermans shown in the image above were reported to have been
photographed on Mezado Ridge on Okinawa on 17
June 1945. The tank in the foreground can be seen with a "1 in
a triangle" on its turret while the one behind it displays a "3 in a
triangle." Period photos show that the 6th (USMC) Tank Battalion
identified its vehicles with a number of geometric shapes, including
circles, triangles, squares, diamonds, clubs and hearts. At dawn on 17
June, the 22nd Regiment of the 6th Marine Infantry Division assaulted
the northern slope of Mezado Ridge. "Tanks...were able to support the
attack firing into caves on the western tip of Mezado
Ridge." The 6th TB had its combat debut on Okinawa and came
ashore with approximately 54 M4A3(75)Ws. Before going into
action, the battalion reported, "Sections of steel track blocks were
spot welded around the turret and on the front slope plate with the
track guides towards the armor face." This is the only scene we know
that shows logs placed on the fronts. From 9 May to 21 June,
the battalion reported the total loss of 21 tanks and drew 26 "Tank,
Medium M4A3" from the Seventh Service Regiment as replacements. Medium
tank losses on Okinawa were much higher than expected, and the USMC
replacement system proved inadequate. It would appear that some
Shermans, including a few remanufactured Ford M4A3s had to be drawn
from Army stocks. We take the tank in the foreground to be such an
example. Judging by the shape of the cast driver's hood, this was a
model built with direct vision.
Flamethrower
Shermans had proven to be potent weapons in several of the Island
Campaigns in the Pacific. More were wanted for the proposed invasion of
Japan scheduled for late 1945. In the Summer of 1945, "Initial issue and
maintenance requirements for next six months estimated at 333 flame
throwers and 91 service units...the assignment of 10 such tanks to each
of 23 tank battalions and 54 flame throwers to the 713 Tank Battalion."
Over 600 M42 series Flamethrowers were ordered, and by the end of
October 1945, 151 remanufactured M4A1s had been converted to M42B1
Flamethrowers in the US. Only 49 M42B3s had been completed, and these
were stated to have been converted from remanufactured "M4A3 and M4A3,
75mm gun, Wet." The project was terminated due to the Japanese
surrender. Some M42 series served post war as training tanks with
various flamethrower units in the US. There are a fair number of
surviving M42B1s, but we are not aware of any M42B3s. The Signal Corps
photos above are the only ones we know that show an M42B3. The captions
are dated 1 February 1956 and feature a flame thrower demonstration by
the 723rd Tank Battalion at the Garlic Springs Firing Range, Camp Irwin,
California. A large plate seen inside the turrets of some surviving
M42B1s suggests that the M. W. Kellogg Company did the M42 conversions.
The surviving M42B1s are all equipped with the E9 modification,
presumably because the Shermans wanted for the invasion of Japan were
required to have HVSS, and E9 was likely considered an acceptable
substitute. We would assume that the 49 M4A3 conversions would have been
similar 1945 remanufactures done by Montreal Locomotive Works, but the
unit seen here doesn't appear to have been retrofitted with the E9
suspension, that is, the suspension is not spaced away from the hull. In
addition, the braces seen on the extended fenders look to be the round,
adjustable type such as used on M4A1(76)s. The tank, which we recorded
as USA 3053782 (Jan. 1943) from the original print at the US Archives,
does have other items that were wanted for the invasion of Japan,
starting with the Ford V8 engine. Desired modifications included the
commander's all round vision cupola (1), the RC-298 Infantry Phone (2),
the armored first aid box (3), and armored exhaust deflector (4). It
does not however, seem to have the improved gunner's pericope with
armored cover. Of course, these photos were taken nearly 11 years after
the M42B3 conversion, so it is likely that it was pulled out of
mothballs and reconditioned, but we can observe that it was never
retrofitted with the torsion bar helper hinges on the engine deck.
In the years following WW II, the Government went back and forth trying
to decide if Shermans with 75mm guns and VVSS should be retained or
scrapped. In March 1946, Headquarters, Army Ground Forces advised "that
75mm gunned medium tanks...were not acceptable." A month later, the
Ordnance Technical Committee recommended obsoletion of all medium tanks
"equipped with 75mm guns and vertical volute spring suspension."
However, "This was not approved by the War Department General Staff."
The disposition of 75mm Shermans with VVSS remained unresolved for
several years. In the meantime, while it is obvious from period photos
that some such Shermans were being used for training, it is assumed that
most were sealed and placed in storage lots throughout the US, such as
the 1950 scene above at the Letterkenny Ordnance Depot in Chambersburg,
Pennsylvania. As they sat out, these tanks appear to have been inspected
from time to time, probably started up, and resealed if necessary. The
inset shows at least 3 date stencils seen on a surviving Sherman. The
top stencil reads "INV[entory?] 12-47", the bottom "6-48-" and the
middle "3-53-C2." We would guess that "C2" might have been a condition
code, indicating the amount of work that would be required to make the
vehicle "ready for issue." On 28 October 1948, OCM Item 32443 approved
obsoletion of "Tank, Medium, M4A3, 75mm, VVSS, (Dry)" as well as the
"Tank, Medium, M4A3E2" [Jumbo, 109 units] with the notation, "Scrap for
parts (Ford engine)." The OCM states that there were 1413 M4A3(75)Drys
in the US inventory, including 120 in use by the National Guard. Recall
that Ford produced a total of 1690 M4A3(75)s. "Dry" meaning "dry
ammunition stowage" was retroactively assigned to Ford M4A3s to
distinguish them from Second Generation Fisher built M4A3(75)s which
were built with "wet ammunition stowage." In any case, not all 75mm
Shermans were declared obsolete at this time. The 2224 M4s and M4A1s
with VVSS were reclassified as "Limited Standard" with the note "Retain
for Foreign Aid." The 638 Fisher built, large hatch M4A3(75)Wet HVSS
were to be retained "for conversion to 76mm" while the 1196 M4A3(75)Wet
VVSS were to be retained "for possible conversion to 76mm and HVSS or
scrap for Ford engine." We try to record Registration Numbers whenever
we come across them, and the tank in the lower right can be seen as USA
3054296, indicating Ford May 1943 production.
A few Signal Corps photos show similar scenes of Shermans and other WW
II AFVs stored at Red River Arsenal in Texas, Benicia Arsenal in
California and the Ordnance Depot in Anniston, Alabama. Rock Island
Arsenal was another facility where excess AFVs were sealed and stored in
the post war years. Some modifications and conversions were done there
as well. RIA actually produced some light and medium tanks in the prewar
years, and certainly would have been capable of doing remanufacturing
jobs, but if they rebuilt any Fords, either during or after WW II, we
can't say that we have come across any official records. The photo above
includes an RIA information panel dated 18 December 1945. The scene is
described as "Building No. 208. Shop R Addition. Turret and track
removal and loading dock." The photo is much larger, but we have zoomed
in on the 5 Shermans on the loading dock next to the railroad tracks. We
see 3 Second Generation, 76mm Shermans and 2 First Generation 75s. The
lead tank can be identified as a Ford M4A3 by the appearance and
position of the antenna bracket. This is entirely speculative, but this
scene may show the installation of the E9 suspension to all of these
tanks and might have been an instance where the mod was "performed
during tank overhauls at Base Shops." Of interest is that at least the
front section of the side fenders (arrows) on the Ford appears to run
under the sponson all the way to the lower hull, whereas the side
fenders provided with the E9 kit only extended "1/2 inch under sponson."
While the kit included a pair of "Fender[s], hull rear", it did not
provide widened front fenders, nor are there any instructions about
using/adapting the old fenders. (We would observe that 9 of the 11
surviving Ford M4A3s that have the E9 Modification are equipped with
front fenders that appear to have been taken from HVSS Shermans.) In any
case, the tanks shown here were not installed with front fenders, and
there are a few period photos that show no front fenders on E9 Shermans
including Ford M4A3s (inset), M4A3(76)s and 105s and M4A1(76)s. The E9
modification kit included 36 flat fender braces and these tanks are
observed with 18 per side as opposed to the 10 seen on WW II era non E9
extended fenders. The absence of front fenders on the Ford M4A3 in the
foreground would have forced the relocation of the siren as shown here.
All of these Shermans are also seen installed with armored first aid
boxes.
Sam Fuller's "The Tanks are Coming" was
released by Warner Brothers in November 1951. Many of the movie's
scenes were filmed at Fort Knox in the summer of 1951, a year after the
start of the Korean War. Of interest, is that the film appears to have
used about a half dozen Ford M4A3s to represent the first platoon of
Company C of an armored regiment of the 3rd Armored Division. Studying
the footage, all of the platoon's M4A3s are noted to be installed with
the full suite of applique armor, armored first aid boxes, commander's
vision cupolas and the E9 modification with flat fender braces. Only
one tank actually has any EECs fitted, and that is the only one noted
without front fenders. In the opening scene, the lead tank,
"CALIF.JANE" appears to be a 1943 production Ford, but in the first
combat scene, she has "become" USA 3055636 (September 1942), a direct
vision model with an early antenna bracket. The tank is knocked out by
an M36 "Panther", and in the bailout scene "CALIF.JANE" suddenly
sprouts EECs and her Registration Number is transformed to USA 3054463
(June 1943). The replacement tank, "CALIF.JANE II" is seen with USA
3054912 painted across the front, indicating September 1943 production,
and is noted with an E8543 differential housing with cast-in steps.
This "CALIF.JANE II" is the only tank in the platoon equipped with a
gun travel lock, which we might assume was factory installed by Ford.
The scene above shows the crew of "CAN CAN", USA 3054468 (June 1943),
bailing out after being hit by a German 88. During a rest break scene
in Mons, "CALIF.JANE II" is now USA 3055703 (September 1942) with an
armored exhaust deflector, infantry phone, armored first aid box and
padded hull lifting rings. The front of the tank is not shown, but we
would expect it would have had direct vision. The tanks are not
equipped with torsion bar hinges or other features of the 1950s
rebuilds, leading us to suspect that they may have been Rock Island
Arsenal overhaul jobs.
In May 1950, exactly one
month before the outbreak of the Korean War, Army officials apparently
had a change of heart, since OCM 332805 reclassified the "Tank, Medium,
M4A3, 75mm, VVSS, (Dry)" from "Obsolete" to "Limited Standard." At that
point, 1181 units were reported to be in the inventory, with 1040 in US
Depots. The 1181 figure is 232 less than the 1948 figure of 1413, so we
might assume that some of the Fords had been salvaged for parts and
scrapped in the intervening years. In any case, these 1181 were "to be
kept available for possible emergency conversion to new weapon." In
January 1951, Bowen-McLaughlin-York was contracted to remanufacture
1493 M4A3(75) and M4A3E2(75)s. The contract did not distinguish between
Ford and Fisher M4A3(75)s, so the number of Ford rebuilds cannot be
determined, but, of course, it would have been no more than the 1181
units in the inventory, assuming the count was accurate. The photo
shows one such example, USA 3053692 which would have been accepted in
December 1942. Of interest is that this is the earliest Ford we can
document with the standard or final type of hull lifting rings, at
least on the front. Earlier we mentioned that some Fords built during
the transition period have been noted to have the final type on the
front and the padded type on the rear (as seen here) or vice versa.
Some stenciling on the side can be read as "May 1952 York, Pa." so we
have a little "when and where." Note that USA 3053692 was never
installed with the side or driver's hood applique plates. When these
are present, we assume that they were applied during WW II, because the
kits would have long since been used up by the 1950s. WW II era
remanufacturing programs generally required the retrofit of the M34A1
gun mount on any Shermans that lacked it. We are somewhat surprised
that that was not the case in the 1950s. USA 3053692 can be seen with
what appears to be a Ford produced M34 gun mount. Due to lack of spare
M34A1s, it is apparent that quite a few 1950s era rebuilds made do
without the direct sight telescope. Fittings suggests that this tank
had been installed with sand shields at some point during WW II.
However, the evidence is that sand shields were removed from any
Shermans that came in with them during the 1950's programs. The surest
sign of a 1950s era remanufactured Ford can be seen on the engine deck.
The 1951 BMY contract included the clause "Coordinate Engineering Order
requirement for installation of torsion bars on engine doors." Thus,
the November 1942 request for a "heavy door" fix was finally addressed.
A bit of one of the torsion bar helper hinges (arrow) can just be seen
on the engine deck of this tank. Counting heads suggests that Fords
remanufactured by BMY were installed with a hinged comb device (1)
which was mounted on the glacis in front of the driver's hood as shown
here. Another clue of a BMY job is the mounting of 3 spare track links
(2) on each side of the turret. Gun travel locks (3), or their
fittings, are present on all of the surviving Ford M4A3s, so it would
seem that they were a required addition of the 1950s rebuilds on tanks
that came in without them. Furthermore, the survivors are noted with
the later wrap around clamp (4) as opposed to the two-fingers clamp
typical of WW II era Shermans. In this case, the gun travel lock is
affixed much further down the glacis than the standard location. If
they had not been moved earlier, the sirens were repositioned from the
left front fender to the glacis and protected with a guard (5).
Bowen-McLaughlin-York
was not the only firm that remanufactured Ford M4A3s in the 1950s.
While we have not been able to locate any historic documentation,
evidence noted on survivors, including a few dataplates, indicates that
the southwestern construction firm, Brown & Root, Inc. of Houston
"reconditioned" a number of Fords in the early 1950s. In fact, there
are more surviving B&Rs than BMYs. At present, we have identified
62 Brown & Root, and 36 Bowen-McLaughlin remanufactures. Minor
differences are noted between the jobs done by the two firms,
particularly in regard to the torsion bar hinges. The typical B&R
torsion bar hinge configuration is shown in the left side photo on SN
2800 in Aitkin, Minnesota. In order to install the torsion bars, it was
necessary to trim the ends of the back plate (1) and remove the side
plates of the original rectangular bullet splash protection on the
forward engine deck. As built, the engine deck doors were secured with
bolts on the inner edges at the front and rear of each door. These were
no longer used, and, in the case of Brown & Root, a single latch
(2) was installed to prevent the doors from popping open during rough
travel. The BMY configuration was similar except that another hold-down
latch was added to the front for greater security. As can be seen on
the right on the M4A3 at the USMC Museum, a good deal of the bullet
splash plate was trimmed away in order to permit the front handle to
pivot. These two photos provide an opportunity to show the difference
between what modelers term a "low bustle" turret as seen on the left
and a "high bustle" turret as on the right. Note how the bottom of the
low bustle practically touches the turret splash, while there is a good
6 or 8 inches (arrow) of clearance on the high bustle. High bustle
turrets brought back the pistol port and introduced the loader's hatch.
They entered the Sherman production pipeline at the end of 1943, well
after Ford had left the program. We don't discount the idea that some
remanufactured Fords could have had their original turrets replaced
with high bustles. However, if SN 11578 had had a high bustle turret
when it was remanufactured at BMY, it is pretty certain that it would
have had spare tracks added to the sides. In this case, we think the HB
turret was installed during a collector's restoration because the tank
had been recovered without a turret.
Some
of the 1950s remanufactured Fords were placed back into US Army Reserve
and National Guard service as training tanks. The above shows an
example that was photographed on 9 June 1954. The caption reads in part,
"The 3007th Station Complement, from Birmingham, Ala., serving two
weeks summer training at Ft. McClellan, gave proficiency tests to its
enlisted personnel. Lt. Lewis Shulhafer tests an enlisted man in the
method of firing on a tank with a small rifle." This M4A3 can be
identified as a BMY rebuild by the hinged comb device (1) and the spare
tracks on the turret. Fords were not built with cable clamps (2) and
footman loops (3) on the differential housings. The evidence suggests
that this combination is typical of BMY, whereas Brown & Root
remanufactures don't show the footman loops and are only randomly
observed with the cable clamp.
Here we have a rear view of SN 2894, the last Ford M4A3 accepted in
October 1942. It is on display at the Carver County Historical Society
and Veterans Services in Waconia, Minnesota. Pierre-Olivier and Dan Reed
photographed this tank on a nice day in September 2018. It can be seen
with the torsion bar hinges in the "Brown & Root configuration" with
a continuous bullet splash on the forward engine deck panel. It is
somewhat unusual to see on survivors, but SN 2894 has managed to retain
its original Registration Number - USA 3055854. The fittings (1) held an
RC-298 Infantry Phone wired through the hole (2) drilled into the rear
plate. Just above that is stamped the tank's serial number, 2894, and
above that is "BR 690" as shown in the inset. We take "BR 690" to be the
Brown & Root "recondition" serial number. If there is not too much
paint, the "BR Number" (sometimes without the BR prefix) can be found
stamped into this area on surviving M4A3s with the torsion bar hinges in
the "Brown & Root configuration." The same number without the BR
prefix has been seen stamped elsewhere on the vehicle such as on the
turret's secondary antenna bracket, the gun and rotor shields and the
differential housing. This might indicate that, when a tank came in for
rebuild, an effort was made to keep the various components together as
the vehicle was disassembled, inspected, repaired, cleaned and
reassembled. The lowest number we have recorded is BR 29 and the highest
is 958. The last strikes us as extremely high considering that there
were only 1181 M4A3 dry stowage Shermans (i.e. Fords) reported to be in
the US inventory in May 1950, and BMY obviously rebuilt quite a few. One
possible explanation is that the Brown and Root numbers were not just
for Ford M4A3s but included other types of Shermans that the company
reconditioned. We have not seen any such numbers on Bowen-Mclaughlin
rebuilds. Unlike BMY, Brown & Root did NOT attach any spare tracks
to the sides of the turrets on the Ford M4A3s they rebuilt.
Moving around to the front of SN 2894, shows what we think was the
appearance of the differential housing when the reconditioned tank left
Brown & Root. Note the absence of footman loops and cable clamp.
While BMY M4A3s are seen with a fairly elaborate hinged comb device
mounted on the glacis in front of the driver's hatch, the B&Rs
appear to have been installed with a simple comb welded to the
differential housing as seen here. The location and look of this comb
suggests that it was based on the one that the Chester Tank Depot
designed and first used around November 1942. The B&R comb is simply
one notch larger than the CTD comb. The left inset provides a
comparison of the B&R and BMY combs. These were used to provide an
external means of locking and unlocking the brakes by the use of wires
attached to the steering levers. This permitted the tanks to be
manipulated into position in a cargo hold or other conveyance without
having to enter the vehicles, thereby ruining the shipping sealing of
the drivers' hatches. The drawing in the inset on the right was provided
by the Chief Ordnance Officer of the Longue Point Ordnance Depot near
Montreal. It references a "Double pulley welded at rear of driver's
seat" and indeed such pulleys have been seen in a few surviving M4A3s.
Ford
M4A3s don't appear to have been widely distributed as Mutual Defense
Assistance in the 1950s. There are two on display at the Real Felipe
Fortress in Callao, Peru. Aside from SN 12390 at the Saumur Tank Museum and 1 restoration project in Canada (as of March, 2024),
these are the only examples we know of at present that are outside of
the US. Both of these show evidence of having been installed with the
torsion bar hinges in the Brown & Root configuration although the
hinges have since been removed. Both appear to have been retrofitted
with nonstandard sand shields that we assume were local modifications.
The Mutual Defense Assistance documents we came across at the US
Archives only go up to 31 January 1954, and there was no listing for
Peru, so if these were provided as MDAP, it must have been after 1954.
There are a small number of still photos online and some newsreel
footage that show a few Ford M4A3s in Peruvian service. Some appear to
have taken part in military coups in July 1962 and October 1968. Two,
along with a large hatch M4A3(75)W with low bustle turret and torsion
bar hinges, are seen in a newsreel captioned, "A massive military parade
through Lima watched by several thousand people highlight Peru's 150th
Independence celebrations on July 29 [1971]. If any readers are
able to fill in the blanks on this subject, we would be pleased to have a
report. Photos courtesy of "Victor12" from Wikipedia.
Most Shermans, including the Fords, were declared obsolete in 1956. Some
were used as range targets, some were provided as tank monuments, but
most were sold off as scrap. Popular Mechanics reported that, in 1958, a
Chicago steel dealer, bought 536 Shermans from Rock Island Arsenal for
$305,388.00. That is less than what a single, fully restored Sherman
might fetch today. The M4A3 in the foreground of the left side photo can
be seen as USA 3054817 (August 1943). Note the Brown & Root
configuration of the torsion bar helper hinges. It is thought that the
M4A3 with E9, SN 12298 (June 1943) in Akron, Ohio (right) might have
come from the RIA lot. As an aside, we would note that this tank has a
Union Steel turret with working pistol port. Union Steel was not one of
Ford's turret suppliers so we would judge that the tank's original
turret, which was likely a welded up or no pistol port turret, was
replaced. It can be seen that the ventilator weep holes (arrow) drain to
the front. The torsion bar helper hinges are in the BMY configuration,
and the turret has weld scars from the studs for spare tracks, so it
seems likely that the turret was on 12298 when it was remanufactured at
BMY. In addition, a single footman loop remains on the differential
housing, but there are weld scars left by the removal of other loop and
the cable clamp as well as the hinged comb in front of the driver's
hatch. We can observe without further comment, that SN 12298 is one of
the 2 out of 11 surviving Ford M4A3s with E9 that does not have front
fenders.
The authors would gladly receive reports from readers who encounter any
Ford M4A3s. Fords are perhaps the easiest Shermans on which to find the
tank serial number, since it was stamped on "the four corners of the
upper hull." It can be found stamped just below both of the hull lifting
rings on the front, and in the areas indicated by the red circles in
the rear. Note that SN 11473 (Nov. 1942), which is on display at the
Military History Institute in Carlisle, Pennsylvania can be seen with
the torsion bar hinges in the BMY configuration. The tank was
retrofitted with the armored plate exhaust deflector at some point
during its service life.
Here are a couple Fords with Serial Numbers we couldn't get due to
extreme paint build up. The M4A3 on the left is on display at the very
nice National Guard Militia Museum of New Jersey in Sea Girt. This one
appeared to have a coat of sand paint on it when we looked at it on a
rainy Christmas Eve over 20 years ago. The fellow with the notebook is
our world travelling Canadian friend, Jim Goetz. We had received a
"rumor" of a Sherman in Antwerp, New York, which we found using the
newfangled (at the time) Google Earth. Jim went down and looked at it,
but again, there was a LOT of paint. Of interest is that this M4A3 has
the standard or final type of hull lifting rings on the front and the
padded type on the rear. The E8543 differential housing with cast in
steps doesn't seem like it would go with that, but this tank appears to
be one that was rebuilt during WW II and again by Bowen-Mclaughlin-York
in the early 1950s.
We don't have the opportunity to get inside of many Shermans, so
dataplate information and/or photos from surviving examples is always
welcome. An original dataplate will include the name of the
manufacturer. These were often replaced with new plates during
remanufacture. The example shown above was photographed inside of the
M4A3 on display at Norwich University in Vermont. The “M’F’D BY” line is
blank, but the tank shows retrofitted features typical of M4A3s rebuilt
by Bowen-McLaughlin-York in the early 1950s. Almost all of the
surviving Ford M4A3s of which we are aware have been rebuilt, in some
cases, more than once. Consequently, we have yet to come across an
original Ford dataplate. Photos courtesy of Steve Tyliszczak.